Scarborough Renaissance

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 16 February 2012

2012-02-13T03:00:00.000Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will now be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 16 February 2012 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. 11/01844/FL - The Sands - Burniston Road - Scarborough

The main item on the agenda will be a presentation of observations regarding the development of The Sands water theme park and its associated holiday accommodation.

The application has raised a number of concerns, and it was felt appropriate to take this opportunity to provide an update on progress.

Further details can be found at:

SBC: 11/01844/FL - The Sands - Burniston Road - Scarborough

2. Design and the Urban Realm

Principally our concerns are design and the urban realm. It has become increasingly important to understand what exactly is meant by that, and how we communicate with the Town Hall, architects and developers. Ensuring we are doing everything possible to enable a better future for both the town and the surrounding area.

With respect to our recent conversations relating to the Moorlands Hotel and the proposed sports facility at the University Campus. The meeting will use them as a basis to discuss how as Urban Space we would like to develop our agenda over the coming year.

3. Any other business

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Bing-Maps link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 09 February 2012

2012-02-02T02:30:00.007Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 09 February 2012 and will start at 19h15.

+++ CANCELLED DUE TO ADVERSE WEATHER +++

Please note that due to heavy snow fall on the day, this month's meeting will now take place on Thursday 16 February 2012. The time, venue and agenda, remain unchanged.

Bing-Maps link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 12 January 2012

2011-12-24T18:00:00.011Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 12 January 2012 and will start at 19h15.

I would also like to take this opportunity to thank everyone for your kind support over the last twelve months; and to wish you all:

Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year !!!

Agenda

1. Proposed New Sports Facility - University of Hull - Scarborough Campus

The first item on the agenda will be an update from the architect responsible for the proposed development of a new sports facility for Scarborough's University Campus on Filey Road. This facility will comprise of a sports hall, fitness suite, studio, seminar rooms, and various supporting changing and social spaces.

Following their earlier presentation to our meeting back in October, the team now have some revised designs available for consideration and would like to talk again to Urban Space as part of their public consultation.

Everyone is encouraged to attend to comment and lend their support. The full application is yet to be submitted, and so this is an opportunity to make a constructive contribution to the process before the proposal is finalised.

Paper copies of the plans will be available for inspection at the meeting.

2. 11/01844/FL - The Sands - Burniston Road - Scarborough

The full application concerning the continued development of The Sands can now be found on the Council's planning portal. The proposal covers all aspects of the site, including holiday lodges and homes, family restaurant, water park, parking, and landscaping.

This item will be the second part of our two month consideration of this proposal.

At our previous meeting in December: we noted our concern regarding the manner in which the application had been handled; the utilisation of the site; and the density and design quality of the holiday homes.

This meeting will further expand and refine our commentary for submission, and will form the basis of a presentation to Town Team later in the month.

Further details can be found at:

SBC: 11/01844/FL - The Sands - Burniston Road - Scarborough

3. Any other business

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 21h00 at the latest.

Bing-Maps link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Planning Decision Archive - 2012

2011-12-24T17:45:00.004Z

Details of the previous decisions of the Council's Planning & Development Committee can be accessed by clicking on the appropriate link:

Planning & Development Committee - 12 January 2012

Future meetings:

Planning & Development Committee - 02 February 2012
Planning & Development Committee - 01 March 2012

Further outcomes to be updated shortly.

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 08 December 2011

2011-12-02T22:32:00.002Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 08 December 2011 and will start at 19h15.

Provisional Agenda

1. 11/01844/FL - The Sands - Burniston Road - Scarborough

The full application concerning the continued development of The Sands can now be found on the Council's planning portal. The proposal covers all aspects of the site, including holiday lodges and homes, family restaurant, water park, parking, and landscaping.

This item will be covered over our next two meetings.

Further details can be found at:

SBC: 11/01844/FL - The Sands - Burniston Road - Scarborough

Other items to follow.

Bing-Maps link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 17 November 2011

2011-11-08T18:45:00.009Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 17 November 2011 and will start at 19h15.

Please note that this month's meeting is taking place a week later than usual.

Agenda

1. Scarborough's Proposed Superstore Developments

Following the late availability of the Independent Retail Assessment Report and the County Council's Highways Report, as well as some minor amendments to both Tesco and Sainsbury's applications, this Thursday's main agenda item will now focus on the store proposals.

Please note, that as the closing date for the consultation process is now Tuesday 29 November 2011, this will be our last and final opportunity as a Group, to comment on two of the most difficult and significant retail proposals to be brought before the town for some years.

Further details of the Tesco application can be viewed at:

SBC: 11/00019/FL- Tesco - Dean Road - Scarborough

Further details of the Sainsbury's application can be viewed at:

SBC: 10/02538/FL - Sainsbury's - Falsgrave Road - Scarborough

Time permitting:

2. 11/01914/OL - Middle Deepdale - Eastfield - Scarborough

An opportunity for members of the Group who may wish to comment on the outline application for 1,350 new dwellings and other associated developments within the area known as Middle Deepdale.

Given the scale of the application, it is recommended that we restrict our review to the detail contained within the Design & Access Statement. Although, other issues can be taken into consideration if you feel they are relevant.

Further details can be found at:

SBC: 11/01914/OL - Middle Deepdale - Eastfield - Scarborough

3. 11/01368/FL - Salisbury Arcade - Huntriss Row - Scarborough

Update on our recent response to this application.

Further details can be found at:

SBC: 11/01368/FL - Salisbury Arcade - Huntriss Row - Scarborough

4. 11/02181/FL - Moorlands Hotel - North Promenade - Whitby

Although strictly speaking a Whitby proposal, you may wish to spend a little time looking at this application to demolish the Moorlands Hotel on North Parade, and replace it with twelve homes.

The Design & Access Statement is quite detailed and worth a view. Particularly, as we have recently expressed concern regarding the quality of such reports submitted as part of the planning process.

Your comments would be welcome.

Further details can be found at:

SBC: 11/02181/FL - Moorlands Hotel - North Promenade - Whitby

5. Londesborough Lodge

A brief update on the establishment of an independent Steering Group to consider the future of this potentially important public asset.

6. Any other business

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Other Notes:

1. 11/01844/FL - The Sands - Burniston Road - Scarborough

The full application concerning the continued development of The Sands can now be found on the Council's planning portal. The proposal covers all aspects of the site, including holiday lodges and homes, family restaurant, water park, parking, and landscaping.

This item will be covered over our next two meetings.

Further details can be found at:

SBC: 11/01844/FL - The Sands - Burniston Road - Scarborough

Bing-Maps link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 20 October 2011

2011-10-11T18:45:00.005+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 20 October 2011 and will start at 19h15.

Please note that this month's meeting is taking place a week later than usual.

Agenda

1. Proposed New Sports Facility - University of Hull - Scarborough Campus

The main item on the agenda will be a presentation from the team responsible for the proposed development of a new sports facility for Scarborough's University Campus on Filey Road. The facility will comprise of a sports hall, fitness suite, studio, seminar rooms, and various supporting changing and social spaces. They now have some designs available for consideration and would like to talk to Urban Space as part of their public consultation.

Everyone is encouraged to attend to comment and lend their support. The full application is yet to be submitted, and so this is an opportunity to make a constructive contribution to the process before the proposal is finalised.

Paper copies of the plans will be available for inspection at the meeting.

2. 11/01368/FL - Salisbury Arcade - Huntriss Row - Scarborough

Comment on the recent application to close the Salisbury Arcade on Huntriss Row.

The consultation period for this application has been extended for an additional two weeks due to the submission of new elevations. Details can be found on the Council's planning portal at:

SBC: 11/01368/FL - Salisbury Arcade - Huntriss Row - Scarborough

The plans can be viewed by clicking on the External Documents tab and then View Associated Documents.

3. Planning, Projects and Other Issues

Updates on both the Tesco and Sainsbury supermarket proposals, and High Mill Farm - Scalby.

4. Any other business

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Bing-Maps link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

IMPORTANT - Links to SBC Planning Portal

2011-10-01T02:45:00.002+01:00

Please note that due to the migration of SBC's planning portal to a new system, NONE of the application references dated before this post are currently valid. All links will in be updated in due course.

Joint Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 29 September 2011

2011-09-26T21:00:00.004+01:00

Please note that on Thursday 29 September 2011 there will be a special joint meeting of the Urban Space Group and Town Team, to be held in the Seaview Room of the Spa Complex, starting at 19h00.

Tesco and Sainsbury store proposals

Its purpose will be to discuss the revised plans for both the Tesco and Sainsbury store proposals. The first half hour will be dedicated to a presentation from the Urban Space Group delegation that met with representatives from Tesco last week, focusing on the amendments to the design and layout of the Dean Road site. The remainder of the meeting will then provide an opportunity for all members of the community to comment as appropriate on the two schemes before us.

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 21h00 at the latest.

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 08 September 2011

2011-08-11T15:00:00.009+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 08 September 2011 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

The main item on the agenda, will be to begin the process of considering a response to the proposals to develop the next stage of The Sands project on the north side of Scarborough. This will be a large and complex application, and therefore this meeting will initially concentrate on matters arising from Benchmark's presentation to last month's Town Team. A special meeting will be arranged once the full application has been submitted.

Other items will include an update on the Planning Committee's decision to approve the discharge of conditions, with respect to the master plan and design code character areas for High Mill Farm - Scalby Village; and the expected publication of the revised proposals for Tesco - Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital.

There was no meeting in August due to our summer break.

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Bing-Maps link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 14 July 2011

2011-07-05T20:00:00.005+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 14 July 2011 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

The main agenda item will be to review the Council's proposals to develop a 'Sports Village' at Weaponness Valley, and the associated treatment of the other two sites at Filey Road Sports Centre and the Athletic Ground on Seamer Road. The discussion will embrace both the various options presented within the documentation, and consideration of how the three interlinked projects can be developed to ensure best urban design practice.

Details and a link to the on-line consultation form can be found at:

SBC: Sports & Leisure Village Consultation

The meeting will also feature a round-up of all our current topics, and an update on recent discussions regarding the future organisation of Scarborough Renaissance.

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 09 June 2011

2011-05-27T00:15:00.008+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 09 June 2011 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

The main agenda item will consider the variation and discharge of various conditions relating to the outline permission to develop the site of High Mill Farm, Scalby. You may remember that this is a rather complex application to build 400+ homes and business units to the north of Scalby village. Given this, what we are proposing to do is to concentrate mainly on the revisions to the masterplan, as we would like to discuss whether we think the developers have produced a scheme appropriate to the site and the wider area. We hope to be joined at the meeting by Matt Diamond of the Planning Department, members of Scalby Village Trust and Scalby & Newby Parish Council.

Copies of the masterplan and design code character areas can be viewed on the website of Signet Planning:

Signet Planning: Design Code - High Mill Farm - Scalby

Further details relating to the various applications can be found at:

SBC: 09/00717/OL - Mixed Use Residential - High Mill Farm - Scalby

In addition, other items will include brief updates regarding the Tesco and Sainsbury store proposals, the Duchy of Lancaster's outline application to construct 155 new dwellings in the village Cloughton, The Street, and news of June's Town Team meeting.

Time permitting, we will also consider an application to develop the site of the Cricketer's Arms on North Marine Road, Scarborough. The proposal covers the building of retirement housing for the elderly, including communal facilities, landscaping, and car parking provision.

Further details can be found at:

SBC: 11/00932/FL - Retirement Home - North Marine Road - Scarborough

Paper copies of the application will be available for inspection at the meeting.

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 12 May 2011

2011-05-04T01:15:00.010+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 12 May 2011 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

The main agenda items will focus on updates with respect to the Tesco and Sainsbury store proposals; a brief overview of a potential development in the village of Cloughton for 155 new dwellings; and in addition, an opportunity for members to discuss the future of Renaissance and the rôle of the Urban Space Group.

Details of Sainsbury's recent proposals regarding alterations to their petrol filling station can be viewed at:

SBC: 11/00668/FL - Sainsburys Petrol Filling Station - Scarborough

Details of the Duchy of Lancaster's outline application to construct 155 new dwellings in the village Cloughton can be found at:

SBC: 11/00759/OL - Duchy of Lancaster - 155 New Dwellings - Cloughton

Additional Information

Details regarding Tesco's specific applications to undertake various works to and surrounding the Gaol on Dean Road can be viewed at:

SBC: 11/00163/LB - Tesco - Repairs to Goal - Dean Road - Scarborough

SBC: 11/00030/LB - Tesco - Demolition of Surrounding Buildings - Dean Road - Scarborough

Details regarding Tesco's and Sainsbury's original applications relating to their respective sites can be viewed at:

SBC: 11/00019/FL - Tesco Dean Road - Scarborough

SBC: 10/02538/FL - Sainsburys Store Extension - Scarborough

Details regarding discussions relating to the Local Development Framework can be viewed at:

SBC: LDF - Planning & Development Committee - Item 5 - 08 April 2011

SBC: LDF - Cabinet - Item 9 - 12 April 2011

Copies of the Council's Interim Housing Position Paper and background documentation can be downloaded from:

SBC: LDF - Interim Housing Position Paper

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 21 April 2011

2011-04-09T16:15:00.005+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 21 April 2011 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Renaissance Update

A brief update on current Renaissance news.

2. Scarborough's Proposed Supermarket Developments

A brief update regarding the progress of the Sainsbury and Tesco planning applications.

3. The Street - William Street Car Park

The main item on the agenda will be a design consultation exercise with the newly appointed building and landscape architects for The Street project.

This is being undertaken as the clients Coast and Moors Voluntary Action wish to submit a revised and improved planning application for the development.

The evening will be a welcome opportunity to view current progress and to encourage everyone within the Group to make a positive contribution towards the second stage of the design process. Paper and electronic versions of the current drawings will be available for inspection, as will a newly produced 3D rendering of the proposal.

Details of The Street's current planning application can be viewed at:

SBC: 10/02101/FL - The Street - William Street Car Park - Scarborough

Previous meetings:

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 14 October 2010

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 10 March 2011

2011-03-08T00:15:00.007Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 10 March 2011 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. The Street - William Street Car Park

An update on progress so far and some good news to start the meeting with!

Details of The Street's current planning application can be viewed at:

SBC: 10/02101/FL - The Street - William Street Car Park - Scarborough

2. Tesco - Dean Road

An update on news and activity since our last meeting, including a short report on the Urban Area Forum public consultation held at the Central Library on Wednesday 16 February 2011.

Details relating to Tesco's planning application can be viewed at:

SBC: 11/00019/FL - Tesco Dean Road - Scarborough

3. Sainsbury's - Falsgrave Road

The main item on tonight's agenda.

A full report on our recent delegate meeting on Thursday 03 March 2011 with representatives from Sainsbury's, followed by a discussion on their latest proposals.

Paper and electronic versions of their updated designs will be available for viewing.

Details relating to Sainsbury's planning application can be viewed at:

SBC: 10/02538/FL - Sainsburys Store Extension - Scarborough

4. High Mill Farm - Scalby

A short report on this housing development, as we await a Reserved Matters application detailing the layout and design of the site and its buildings.

Further details can be viewed on the website of Signet Planning:

Signet Planning: Design Code - High Mill Farm - Scalby

5. The Small Casino Licence

An opportunity to comment on matters surrounding the recent re-emergence of the casino bid in the news. Please note that this final topic for discussion only relates to potential sites and their implications, not issues concerning the licence.

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Tesco Consultation - Library - Wed 16 February 2011

2011-02-15T18:00:00.014Z

Please note that this Wednesday 16 February 2011 between 15h00 and 20h00, an exhibition event has been organised at the Central Library, Vernon Road, Scarborough. Regarding Tesco's recent application to build a new store on Dean Road:

SBC: 11-00019-FL - Tesco Dean Road - Scarborough

Tesco, the Urban Space Group, and many other local groups and organisations will be there to help answer any questions and present their own observations, on one of the most potentially significant redevelopment proposals to impact upon Scarborough for some years.

All members of the general public are invited to attend, so please take this opportunity to come along and register your comments.

We will look forward to seeing you all.

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 10 February 2011

2011-02-07T22:37:00.007Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 10 February 2011 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Tesco - Dean Road

The first item is an opportunity to catch up with all the recent news relating to Tesco's proposal for Dean Road:

- Update and notes from the delegate meeting with Scarborough Borough Council

- Comment invited regarding our draft response as circulated

- Urban Area Forum public consultation Wednesday 16 February 2011 at the Central Library

Full details relating to Tesco's planning application can be viewed at:

SBC: 11/00019/FL - Tesco Dean Road - Scarborough

2. Sainsbury's - Falsgrave Road

Having had to defer this particular item from last month's meeting, the second and main topic on the agenda will be to consider Sainsbury's recently submitted application to extend their existing store off Falsgrave Road:

SBC: 10/02538/FL - Sainsburys Store Extension - Scarborough

A copy of CABE's recent recommendations on supermarket led development, can be found at:

CABE: Supermarket Led Development - Asset or Liability?

Notes from the previous meeting regarding our refined response to Tesco will be posted soon.

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 13 January 2011

2011-01-09T18:15:00.001Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 13 January 2011 and will start at 19h15.

I would also like to take this opportunity to thank everyone for your kind support over the last twelve months; and to wish you a:

Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year

Agenda

The main agenda items will include an update on the imminent submission of Tesco's planning application for the Dean Road site, our delegate meeting with the Tesco architects earlier this week, and news on the potential future structure of Scarborough Renaissance.

The meeting will also consider Sainsbury's recently submitted application to extend their existing store off Falsgrave Road:

SBC: 10/02538/FL - Sainsburys Store Extension - Scarborough

A copy of CABE's recent recommendations on supermarket led development, can be found at:

CABE: Supermarket Led Development - Asset or Liability?

Notes from the previous meeting regarding our detailed response to Tesco will be posted soon.

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Planning Decision Archive - 2011

2011-01-09T18:00:00.026Z

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 09 December 2010

2010-11-23T02:00:00.003Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 09 December 2010 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Tesco - Dean Road

The one and only item will be a presentation on the Tesco proposal for Dean Road. This will be followed by an open discussion with respect to the development's design, layout and impact on the surrounding urban fabric of the town.

Please note that as there will be no Town Team meeting this month, this may be your only opportunity to discuss the design implications of this major edge of town-centre site, prior to Tesco submitting their planning application. So we do hope that you will be able to join everyone at the Royal Hotel for the meeting.

Tesco's recent digital presentation to the Planning Committee, and paper copies of their current design proposal for the site, will be available for viewing.

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

10/01612/FL - King Street - USG Response

2010-11-23T01:45:00.002Z

Planning Application - King Street - Scarborough

We have recently received a request from the Planning Department of Scarborough Borough Council, to comment upon a recent submission to extend the time limit relating to application reference 06/02273/FL, for the development of 14 residential flats on land on the east side of King Street, Scarborough:

SBC: 10/01612/FL - 14 Residential Flats - King Street - Scarborough

Following meetings of the Urban Space Group on Thursday 04 November 2010 and Thursday 11 November 2010, we would like to record our recommendation to refuse an extension to the deadline for the above planning permission.

In summary:

1. Any development along King Street should be a continuation of the terrace row and this implies that with respect to this particular site, the southern elevation should present a blank aspect to the car park.

2. Clearly the active frontage of this elevation, providing balcony extensions to interior living space and views to the south, does not fulfil this requirement.

3. In order to make allowances for sufficient natural light to fall upon the southern elevation and to ensure residents of the development continue to enjoy a reasonable level of privacy and quiet enjoyment; any future build on the car park would have to commence at least 20 metres from the boundary of the proposed apartments, possibly taking the form of a stepped construction away from said apartment block.

4. We believe that this would limit the subsequent development of any new build on the car park and hence restrict enhancements to the area as part of the broader long-term objective to regenerate The Futurist and its surroundings.

5. The Group do accept that at the time of the Appeal that the Council's plans for the area were uncertain. However, we now believe that following the consultation activity during the summer and subsequent reports, it is reasonable to assume that the area surrounding The Futurist will be developed and hence this application should be refused.

6. The Group are aware that the Applicant already has planning approval for an apartment block of ten flats on the site, which is an appropriate continuation to the terracing on King Street and would not impede any proposals on land to the south.

7. The Group would like to enquire if there is now any requirement to make provision for affordable housing as part of this residential development.

8. The Group would also like to know if there is any associated 106 agreement.

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 11 November 2010

2010-11-07T15:30:00.007Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 11 November 2010 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Planning, Projects & Issues

A quick update on a number of issues currently of interest to the Urban Space Group:

- Designs for the proposed new Outer Harbour facilities
- Station Area Master Plan
- Scarborough Town Centre & Street Scene

2. Planning Application: The Street - William Street Car Park - Scarborough

The main item on the agenda will be to consider the recent planning application submitted for the proposed new £6.2 million youth centre for Scarborough named The Street, on the site of the William Street car park:

SBC: 10/02101/FL - The Street - William Street Car Park - Scarborough

Aspects of the proposal we'll be looking to specifically comment upon:

- Size and massing of the development
- Proximity to residential buildings
- External appearance
- Its setting and landscaping

3. Planning Application: 14 Residential Flats - King Street - Scarborough

A quick résumé of the application and issues relating to the future development of the area surrounding The Futurist theatre following our special meeting last week.

Details of the proposal to extend the deadline for the residential block can be viewed on the SBC planning portal:

SBC: 10/01612/FL - 14 Residential Flats - King Street - Scarborough

Paper copies will be available for inspection.

4. Any other business.

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Special Meeting - 13h30 Thursday 04 November 2010

2010-10-31T22:30:00.004Z

Planning Application - King Street - Scarborough

We have recently received a request from the Planning Department of Scarborough Borough Council, to comment upon a recent submission to extend the time limit relating to application reference 06/02273/FL, for the development of 14 residential flats on land on the east side of King Street, Scarborough:

SBC: 10/01612/FL - 14 Residential Flats - King Street - Scarborough

To this end, there will be a special meeting of the Urban Space Group this coming Thursday 04 November 2010 in the Gazebo at the rear of the Town Hall on King Street.

The meeting will be organised as a 'drop-in' session between 12h00 and 13h30, followed by a 'formal' meeting between 13h30 and 14h00 to discuss our response.

The gazebo was the public desk for the planning department and is now utilised as a meeting room.

Paper copies of the plans, design statement, and both the Planning Committee and appeal decisions, will be available for viewing.

History:

Planning approval for development of this site has something of a complicated history and is one that we as a group have followed. The first submission 06/02273/FL was originally refused by the Planning Committee back in June 2007 but was subsequently granted approval in February 2008 following an appeal.

Approval was granted on the basis that development would begin within three years of the decision. As this period is close to expiration the applicants are now seeking an extension to the time limit:

SBC: 06/02273/FL - 14 Residential Flats - King Street - Scarborough

Note:

In addition to this original submission, there was a further application made regarding the site in August 2007, reference 07/01574/FL, for a revised scheme limiting the number of flats to 10 and the southern elevation effectively presenting a 'blank face' to the car park.

Permission for this development was granted in October 2007 subject to conditions and is not the proposal currently under consideration:

SBC: 07/01574/FL - 10 Residential Flats - King Street - Scarborough

If anybody wants to come along on the day you will be very welcome. We understand that it may be difficult for many of you to make this particular Thursday lunchtime but regrettably our next scheduled meeting is after the closing date for responses, and so something had to be arranged at short notice. With this in mind, we will of course be only to happy to take into consideration any comments received prior to 04 November 2010.

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 14 October 2010

2010-10-11T01:30:00.001+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 14 October 2010 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

The main item on the agenda will be a presentation from Sarah Fenwick, Enterprise Manager for Coast & Moors Voluntary Action, of the new proposal for a £6 million youth centre for Scarborough named The Street, on the site of the William Street coach park.

The team must submit the planning application by the 21st October 2010, and would be grateful for any comment or assistance we could provide in relation to the architectural design and landscaping for the proposal.

We would therefore encourage everyone to attend if possible, as this will probably be our last opportunity for some time to provide much needed facilities for the young people of the town.

Scarborough Evening News - The Street

Further to the main item, there will also be a short update on the Station Area development plan and the designs for the Outer Harbour facilities.

A full copy of our report on the Futurist to the Borough Council Futurist Task Group is now available on our blogsite. Details of last Friday's Corporate Strategy Overview and Scrutiny Committee, and associated documentation can be found at:

Scarborough Borough Council - Final Report of the Futurist Task Group

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Report - The Futurist - Introduction

2010-09-29T23:45:00.013+01:00

Urban Space Group Meeting
Thursday 26 August 2010
The Renaissance Centre

RESPONSE TO THE SBC FUTURIST TASK GROUP ON BEHALF OF THE URBAN SPACE GROUP - INTRODUCTION

The Future of the Futurist Site

The potential embodied in the area surrounding the Futurist theatre is of immense importance to the image and future of Scarborough as a destination, as a seaside resort and as a rewarding place to live and work. For this reason, any proposals for the Futurist site must consider the impact on its immediate surroundings, on Scarborough as a whole and on the region.

For the purposes of our discussion, the implied “site” of the Futurist – and the area that should be considered when assessing any proposal for redevelopment and / or improvement – is assumed to be the block bounded by Foreshore Road, Blands Cliff, King Street, the Futurist steps and the existing buildings on Eastborough, plus the gardens, streets and other spaces around and within this block.

This Document

The comments, observations and conclusions presented within this document are a result of several meetings and a workshop held by the Urban Space Group over the last three years.

These are as follows:

Meeting held at the Royal Hotel - Thursday 08 July 2010
Meeting held at the Royal Hotel - Thursday 10 June 2010
Meeting held at the Palm Court Hotel - Thursday 13 September 2007
Workshop held at the Renaissance Office - Saturday 18 August 2007

The Group also drew upon comments made at the following Town Team meetings:

Meeting held at the Royal Hotel - Tuesday 19 June 2007
Meeting held at the Royal Hotel - Tuesday 15 May 2007

The document is a Group submission. Individual contributions have been credited where requested.

Document Presentation

Due to the length of this report the document has been split into five parts. Convenient links to each section can be found under 'USG Report - The Futurist', within the right hand coloumn of this page, or follow the navigation link below:

Part 1 >

Chair – Urban Space Group - Sunday 05 September 2010

USG Report - The Futurist - Part 1

2010-09-29T23:40:00.003+01:00

Urban Space Group Meeting
Thursday 26 August 2010
The Renaissance Centre

RESPONSE TO THE SBC FUTURIST TASK GROUP ON BEHALF OF THE URBAN SPACE GROUP - PART 1

Key Points

1. The Urban Space Group will only be commenting on the development of the current site and surrounding area and will not be make a formal representation as the retention or otherwise of the current theatre. It was felt that this was outside the remit of the Group, and that if there were members of the Group that wished to make such a representation, there were other more suitable forums or groups whereby their opinion on that matter could be made.

2. Accordingly, the Group has chosen to split their response into two parts. The first part ‘General Recommendations’ is a set of recommendations that we feel should be taken into consideration irrespective of whether a theatre is retained on the site or not. The second part ‘Retention of theatre and / or performance space / facility’, constitutes an additional set of recommendations to be applied, should the decision be taken to support the continued presence of some form of theatre or performance space within the defined area.

3. In fact, given the potential difficulties in attempting to assess market conditions in say five years time, it is advisable and perfectly reasonable to draft a development brief that offers potential investors the option of developing the site either with or without a theatre. Any such condition of sale or otherwise would be supported by the outcome and subsequent decisions thereby taken as a result of the current consultation process.

4. The Group wish it to be made known that they deplore the current state of affairs and are extremely saddened that the situation has been allowed to deteriorate to the present circumstances.

5. The Group are concerned that during the recent presentations made at the Futurist Task Group sessions at the Town Hall, that none of the potential options for the site appeared viable given the current economic climate. It is sincerely hoped that as a Renaissance town of some note we can collectively find a way to circumvent these conditions and deliver a sustainable development of real quality and character.

6. We are particularly concerned that the theatre may close at the end of 2010. Irrespective of the future of the theatre, we do not feel it is advisable to leave ourselves with the edifice of a dead and decaying building in such a prominent location on the town’s foreshore. Therefore we would advise that the theatre continue to operate in some form until future development is secured.

7. The Group would again like to emphasise that this site cannot be developed without taking into consideration the wider area, a philosophy set down within the town’s own ‘Kissing Sleeping Beauty’ document outlining its strategy for regeneration. In support of this, commentary made at a Town Team meeting in June 2007 regarding the general Foreshore area of the South Bay, has been included within Appendix B of this document.

8. Diagrams highlighting the importance of links to the surrounding area, pathways, connections and views can be found in Appendix A. The diagrams also illustrate some potential options for the siting and orientation of any new build.

9. The Group would like to emphasise the potential benefits of opening up the site as the subject of an international design competition. We feel that this would greatly raise the profile of the site on offer, the town, and also help raise the overall standard of design of the subsequent development.

10. The Group would expect the development to be rigorously controlled by a full and proper master plan, and that any proposed changes to any part of the plan are subject to a clear and public change management process.

11. The site has a history of entertainment stretching back over a hundred years. Regardless of the future of the theatre, the site’s identity as a destination for entertainment should not be lost. We would in any eventuality be concerned about the continuing cumulative impact of closing facilities and attractions.

12. To ensure this continued connection, the Group strongly advocates an imaginative and flexible interpretation of the space, as this will be essential in making the project commercially viable and sustainable. We believe the town needs development that can act as an inspiration for all and encourage further investment in high quality projects.

13. We would particularly like to stress the importance of enhancing the site within an overall vision for the South Bay. Its development cannot be viewed in isolation and it is essential that it fits within a cohesive strategy for the whole of the seafront.

14. Further to this, any solution must form an integral part of the town’s overall entertainment, leisure and tourism strategy.

< Introduction Part 2 >

USG Report - The Futurist - Part 2

2010-09-29T23:35:00.004+01:00

Urban Space Group Meeting
Thursday 26 August 2010
The Renaissance Centre

RESPONSE TO THE SBC FUTURIST TASK GROUP ON BEHALF OF THE URBAN SPACE GROUP - PART 2

General Recommendations

1. Any development of the Futurist site as defined above should respect and enhance the existing pattern and character of Scarborough. Situated where it is, between the larger block structure of the Victorian upper town, the expanse of the seafront and the dense, complex pattern of the mediaeval town, the site has the potential to accommodate large buildings, but these must be broken down in scale and punctuated by paths, alleys and small open spaces as seen in the older parts of the town.

2. The block containing the Futurist is flanked by three unique and important spaces – the gardens to the south, the seafront to the east and Blands Cliff to the north – but the existing buildings and walls completely ignore, and are ignored by, these spaces. Indeed, the existing buildings adopt a defensive – even threatening – attitude to their surroundings. Any new buildings or improvements to the existing buildings should open up to, interact with and celebrate these special parts of Scarborough.

3. Hence, a contextual dialogue must be established and active frontages developed to:

- Foreshore Road and the beach
- Gardens to the south
- King Street to the west
- Blands Cliff to the north

4. Related to point 3 above, the block containing the Futurist constitutes a barrier to movement in this part of Scarborough, which contributes to the isolation and threatening nature of its immediate surroundings. There are, however, implied connections between Blands Cliff and the gardens to the rear of the Futurist and between Prospect Place and King Street across the upper part of the site. The completion of these connections – and others – across the site should be a required part of any development in this area.

5. Connectivity is an important concept in modern theories of urban design and it is essential that these routes be established as public thoroughfares; it would defeat the purpose if the routes were established as part of a private, privileged or “gated” development of the site.

6. Hence, increased pedestrian connectivity essential for successful scheme – look at the urban grain of the old town as a precedent.

7. Contributing to the safety, attractiveness and commercial potential of the Futurist site, any new buildings facing the gardens, Foreshore Road and Blands Cliff should be designed to open up to the views as much as possible and present an inviting frontage to passers-by.

8. Of particular importance to the site and to the commercial potential (in depth) of any development will be the south-facing edge facing the Futurist steps. This offers great possibilities for cafes and restaurants positioned to take full advantage of the views across the gardens beyond and the sunny, warm orientation. Any appropriate development of the site could open out onto the gardens.

9. There may be some potential to blur or soften the southern boundary between the site and the gardens, as they are both (together with the steps) controlled by Scarborough council. This could involve a small amount of appropriately designed building extending into the gardens and also part of the gardens by return extending into the site. Perhaps taking the form of an enclosed Winter Garden in conjunction with suitable commercial content, thereby adding appreciably to the bad-weather attractions along the seafront.

10. Any large-scale development along Foreshore Road, whether including the existing Futurist or a new theatre, would create a dark void to the rear, as currently exists between the Futurist and the cliff. This, however, is ideal for any use which does not require daylight or views, such as a multi-screen cinema or possibly even a casino. If indeed such a proposal for a suitable new casino development would gain approval. The roof level of such a development would then create a new, false ground-level above the roofs of buildings on Foreshore Road. This could be an ideal location for a hotel or residential development, as a building or buildings here would enjoy sea views, while not occupying valuable street frontage.

11. Buildings along King Street could have commercial uses at ground level with other uses above, but should also be designed to act as a welcoming “gateway” to all other uses on the site, with ease of access from the top of the cliff down to the seafront being designed into the complex as a whole.

12. In fact, a creative approach to changing levels within the site – possibly linking a series of small spaces stepping down within the development and filled with interest and invitation, would add to its unique potential.

13. Servicing of any development on this site will be a critical part of any proposal. While small-scale servicing of low-intensity uses may be possible from King Street. If site requires more substantial servicing elements, the service zone needs to be accessed via Foreshore Road. However, this does not necessarily lead to a bleak service door blighting part of the seafront, as temporary and moveable uses, such as stalls, café tables and street-performers, can occupy the space at all other times.

14. It is recommended that as part of any development, careful consideration be given to the transport links and pathways down to Foreshore Road. Including, Valley Road, the Aquarium Top Car Park, St. Nicholas Cliff, Blands Cliff, Eastborough, Sandside, and in front of the terracing under the Grand Hotel. Ensuring proper provision is made for people wishing to visit the area, whether by foot, car, coach or bicycle.

15. Leisure activities will form the main activity on the site. Some prestige apartments and incorporation of other visitor attractions such as a cinema, casino or skating rink, are also probably essential in order to insure the commercial viability of the development.

16. There would be many of these facilities which would not require frontage; for example, a multiplex cinema, casino, or ice rink. These could be situated in the natural void between the footprint of the current theatre and the King Street area.

17. Other uses that could be incorporated within the site, other than a theatre, to aid its commercial viability and enhance the quality of the area as a whole, may include:

Introverted / Subterranean Uses:

- Casino
- Cinema

Culturally Related / Kinetic Expression:

- Family entertainment
- Cafés / restaurants / bars
- Workshops / dance studios
- Art galleries / art studios

High Value / 24 Hour Life on Site:

- Residential high quality apartments
- Prime location holiday apartments

18. Please also refer to Appendix A – orientation, views, links & connections.

< Part 1 Part 3 >

USG Report - The Futurist - Part 3

2010-09-29T23:30:00.004+01:00

Urban Space Group Meeting
Thursday 26 August 2010
The Renaissance Centre

RESPONSE TO THE SBC FUTURIST TASK GROUP ON BEHALF OF THE URBAN SPACE GROUP - PART 3

Retention of theatre and / or performance space / facility

1. Should the decision be reached that the Futurist theatre be retained on this site, either in the form of the existing 2,000+ seat auditorium and stage (as distinct from the external shell of the existing building) or as a new 2,000 seat theatre to be constructed as an integral part of any redevelopment of the site. The development brief to be prepared for this site should ensure that the theatre – whether retained or new – is one of the first parts of any development to be completed.

2. Closure of the building is inevitable, even for refurbishment. It is therefore essential to attempt to mitigate any such disruption to the provision of entertainment or other leisure activities in the area.

3. The site has a history of entertainment stretching back over a hundred years. An imaginative and flexible interpretation of the space will be essential to make the project commercially viable and sustainable, thereby ensuring its continued existence.

4. Much of the debate regarding the future of a theatre on this site has concentrated on whether the facility should be designed for an audience of either 1,000 or 2,000 people. This lacks ambition and misses the obvious potential of a performance venue in this location.

5. For example, any theatre-related activity facing onto Foreshore Road could take full advantage of the expanse of sand in front of the site to include the possibility of an outdoor stage at high level (first or second floor) facing the beach. The debate should therefore be about whether a performance might attract 2,000 people (in the internal theatre) or 5,000+ people on the beach.

6. As has been demonstrated by many successful outdoor events held in Scarborough, the boost to all local businesses could be substantial. This would offer a significantly different performance space to that of the Open Air Theatre, thereby adding to and complimenting the current existing facilities available in the town.

7. Perhaps this appears a little farfetched, but the principal is to encourage the exploration of all potential solutions. Whether it is the development of an indoor space that can be adjusted to suit different forms of performance and audience, or as previously suggested, taking advantage of the potential for creating an outdoor amphitheatre. This might be for a few thousand on the beach, or a couple of hundred in the gardens or on the pavement in front of the theatre itself.

8. Any solution should form an integral part of the town’s overall entertainment, leisure and tourism strategy.

9. The delivery of large scenery items to the theatre would be most possible from Foreshore Road - Please also refer to General Recommendations - Point 13

10. To reiterate the previous points, the wider site context must be developed as a whole as opposed to simply approaching the theatre in isolation.

11. If developed, The Futurist should become an iconic urban landmark and employ a ‘seaside’ philosophy of creativity, endeavour and adventure.

< Part 2 Appendix A >

USG Report - The Futurist - Appendix A

2010-09-29T23:25:00.023+01:00

Urban Space Group Meeting
Thursday 26 August 2010
The Renaissance Centre

RESPONSE TO THE SBC FUTURIST TASK GROUP ON BEHALF OF THE URBAN SPACE GROUP - APPENDIX A

Appendix A – Orientation, views, links & connections

USG Report - The Futurist - Appendix B

2010-09-29T23:20:00.007+01:00

Urban Space Group Meeting
Thursday 26 August 2010
The Renaissance Centre

RESPONSE TO THE SBC FUTURIST TASK GROUP ON BEHALF OF THE URBAN SPACE GROUP - APPENDIX B

Appendix B - Foreshore Road

Town Team Meeting - Tuesday 15 May 2007

This Group looked at the future of Foreshore Road which is Scarborough’s “shop window”. Compared with the improving Sandside, the appearance of Foreshore Road leaves something to be desired. The most recent Lonely Planet Guide to Britain said that Scarborough was a nice place except for the Foreshore Road which was tatty and dated. Positive action is needed to bring this area up to modern expectations. Significant improvements are needed to the image and appearance of the area, to the road, buildings and facilities offered.

1. Roads and Paving

We should remove the central reservation, reduce the width of the road, reduce the number of on-street parking spaces and widen the pavements. Pedestrians should be given greater priority in redesigning the “floorscape”.

Subject to technical investigations by professionals, we think that the road and pavements should be raised to improve sea defences rather than the introduction of an unsightly sea wall.

The unsightly railings and barriers around the traffic lights at the junction with Eastborough should be removed, create a better environment as has had been done in Kensington High Street.

The quality and standard of public lighting in the area should be improved.

We need more seating for the public, more “cafe culture” with outside tables on widened pavements.

2. Buildings

The underground Aquarium Top car park is in poor condition and, because of that, it is little used. However, it is well located and is an important asset. Public or private sector investment must be made to bring this car park back into use because it can provide parking space for beach users and hotel guests at the Grand Hotel and St Nicholas Hotel. Developers of the Futurist site could be asked to invest in the car park because it would be of benefit to them, should there be a new casino, theatre or cinema on the Futurist site.

We need an information centre at the Rotunda.

We need to preserve and enhance the shelters on Foreshore Road next to St Nicholas Gardens and retain seating on the roof of this shelter.

The West Pier should be the visible focal point of the Foreshore and a major attraction to all visitors. The West Pier area could be developed with some attractive new buildings and still retain the space and buildings needed for the fishing industry.

The Olympia site should be redeveloped together with the undeveloped terrace below the Grand Hotel. St. Thomas Hospital needs a new use and the derelict land to the rear of the building tidied up. The shop fronts in St. Thomas Hospital and indeed along the Foreshore generally, need improvement.

There is scope for redeveloping or rebuilding some of the poor buildings along the Foreshore Road but there should be no tower blocks and any redevelopment in this area should maintain views of the old town and castle.

We need to find a way of introducing residential occupation to the first floors above shops.

3. The Beach

We need to support activities on the beach, for example providing better facilities for surfers such as changing rooms and showers at the Aquarium Top end. The beach itself should be kept fairly free of clutter and the quality of the existing beach franchises should be improved.

4. Access to the Foreshore Area

The park and ride service should drop visitors somewhere close to the Foreshore so that it will encourage people to use the proposed park and ride facility.

In town, there needs to be comfortable sheltered waiting areas for park and ride buses.

There needs to be a taxi rank close to the Foreshore Road / Sandside area and a convenient coach pick up and drop off point.

The pedestrian links from the town centre “above” and the Foreshore “below” need to be improved and made more obvious. The appearance of Blands Cliff needs to be improved as it has the potential to be an attractive way down to the beach. The unsightly steps down the side of the Futurist should be closed and people directed down through the gardens or through a future redevelopment of the Futurist site.

< Appendix A

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 09 September 2010

2010-09-06T23:45:00.003+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 09 September 2010 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Outer Harbour Facilities & Station Area Master Plan Update

A very brief update regarding these current activities.

2. Scarborough Town Centre & Highways

Brief update on future proposals to develop a master plan for Scarborough town centre.

3. The Futurist Consultation Response

Brief review of August's meeting and response to the Futurist Task Group consultation.

4. Future USG Programme

An opportunity to review and contribute to the USG's future programme.

Current areas of interest include amongst others:

- Raising Design Standards
- Planning & Planning Policy
- Housing Allocations & Community Policy
- Strategy, Funding & the Management Investment Plan
- The Futurist & Foreshore Road
- Station Area & Scarborough Town Centre
- Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital
- The Spa Complex & other capital projects
- Outer Harbour, West Pier & the sea front
- Sainsbury's, Manor Road Park & Old Railway Line
- Linear Park, Oliver's Mount & The Mere
- Middle Deepdale & Cayton
- Signage and Street Furniture
- The nature of 'Place' - exploring the theory

5. Any Other Business

The presentation on the master plan for Station Square has again been deferred.

Date of next meeting: 19h15 Thursday 14 October 2010 – Royal Hotel

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - Important Notice

2010-08-12T02:00:00.008+01:00

Please be reminded that there will be no meeting tonight of the Urban Space Group - Thursday 12 August 2010. This is in accordance with our usual practice of taking a break during August.

However, there will be a special meeting later in the month to discuss our response to the current consultation regarding the future of the site of the Futurist theatre.

The time and date for this meeting is 19h15 on Thursday 26 August 2010 at the Renaissance Office.

If you would like to attend but for any reason can not make this date, please inform us as soon as you can and we will investigate the possibility of making alternative arrangements.

Please note that as agreed at previous meetings, the Urban Space Group will not be debating whether the current theatre should be retained, but will be making an early representation as to the principles underlying the redevelopment of the site and its surrounding area. A draft document for discussion will be circulated in advance of the meeting this weekend.

The Town Hall will be holding a separate consultation with respect to the drafting of the development and design briefs later in October this year.

Further details and documentation relating to the current consultation can be found at:

SBC - Futurist Consultation

The meeting outcome will be posted shortly.

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 08 July 2010

2010-07-03T00:15:00.011+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 08 July 2010 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Outer Harbour Facilities & Station Area Master Plan Update

A very brief update regarding these current activities.

2. The Futurist

Short review of current issues and agreed statement on behalf of the Urban Space Group.

SBC - Futurist Task Group - July Public Meetings

3. Raising Design Standards

Report from the recent CABE sponsored conference organised by BEAM - Raising Design Quality across the Yorkshire & Humber region.

4. Future USG Programme

An opportunity to review and contribute to the USG's future programme.

The presentation on the master plan for Station Square has again been deferred.

In addition to the above, we will as usual carry the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including when appropriate the following items:

1. Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital
2. Signage and Street Furniture
3. Strategy, Funding & the Management Investment Plan
4. The Spa Complex & other capital projects
5. Sainsbury's, Manor Road Park & Old Railway Line
6. Outer Harbour, West Pier & the sea front
7. Linear Park, Oliver's Mount & The Mere
8. Middle Deepdale & Cayton
9. The nature of 'Place' - exploring the theory

The meeting is scheduled to finish by 20h45 at the latest.

A special meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Renaissance Office, Falconers Road, Scarborough, on Thursday 26 August 2010 and will start at 19h15.

Additional details will be posted shortly.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 10 June 2010

2010-05-24T23:30:00.007+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 10 June 2010 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Outer Harbour Facilities

Short update on progress regarding the proposals for the new Outer Harbour facilities, following their submission to the Regional Design Review Panel last month.

2. The Futurist

The main item on the agenda will be a discussion relating to recent issues raised regarding the future of The Futurist and its surrounding area.

- Review of previous USG discussions
- Feedback from Wednesday's Task Group meeting
- Open forum discussion
- Setting design & development principles
- Agreed response & further action

If you wish to attend any of the Futurist Task Group consultant and stakeholder meetings, as members of the general public are welcome (although only as observers), details can be found by following the link below:

SBC - Dates for FTG consultant & stakeholder meetings

A collection of previous plans, documents and consultations associated with The Futurist can be found on the Council's website, by following the link below:

SBC - Previous documents and consultations

3. Signage and Street Furniture

Short update on current progress.

We can now confirm that the presentation on the master plan for Station Square has been deferred until next month.

In addition to the above, we will as usual carry the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including when appropriate the following items:

1. Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital
2. Raising Design Standards & the Planning Process
3. Strategy, Funding & the Management Investment Plan
4. The Spa Complex & other capital projects
5. Sainsbury's, Manor Road Park & Old Railway Line
6. Outer Harbour, West Pier & the sea front
7. Linear Park, Oliver's Mount & The Mere
8. Middle Deepdale & Cayton
9. The nature of 'Place' - exploring the theory

Notes from the previous meeting

John Riby voiced his support for our proposal to undertake a project relating to street clutter and what can be sensibly done to further improve Scarborough's street scene. This is certainly something that we will look to progress at future meetings. We were also very pleased to hear John state that the Council would be looking to develop a master plan for the town, and very much hoped that the Urban Space Group would be able to play a full rôle in the consultation.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Manor Road Playground - Official Opening

2010-05-24T23:15:00.008+01:00

The grand opening of the Manor Road Park Play Area by Councillor Janet Jefferson will take place this Saturday 29 May 2010 between the hours of 11h00 and 12h00.

Please come along and join in the celebrations, including an hour of fun and games with the Friends of Manor Road Park.

Refreshments and barbecue available.

The original consultation event:

Manor Road Playground - Saturday 28 March 2009

It's very impressive what has been achieved over the last year!

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 13 May 2010

2010-04-22T23:50:00.006+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 13 May 2010 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Outer Harbour Facilities

The opening item on the agenda will provide an opportunity to inspect the further refined drawings for these facilities prior to their submission to the Regional Design Review Panel for consideration later this month.

Our Regional Design Review Panal based in Leeds is one of a series of such DRPs across the country. These advisory committees are made up of experts drawn from England's architectural, built environment and creative fields (generally a mix of local and national names) and are aimed at giving impartial input to projects at the design stage - an idea that has been supported by the USG. They have already proved to be beneficial to schemes by way of ensuring the maintenance of high design standards across key projects and in procuring sensitive, site-enhancing solutions.

2. The rôle of the Urban Space Group

A brief comment on the rôle of the Urban Space Group with respect to the Station Area master plan and The Futurist.

3. Signage and Street Furniture

A discussion on the vexed question of signage and general street clutter.

4. The nature of 'Place' - exploring the theory

The final agenda item is a theory-based piece designed to complement the USG's regular programme, offering a short presentation on a concept lying at the heart of urban design theory: the nature of 'Place'. The presentation will begin to explore the notion of genius loci, amongst others, and will be followed by a chance for discussion, offering the opportunity to share thoughts on the subject, and in particular on the subject of how we perceive our own town in such terms.

In addition to the above, we will as usual carry the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including when appropriate the following items:

1. Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital
2. Raising Design Standards & the Planning Process
3. Strategy, Funding & the Management Investment Plan
4. The Spa Complex & other capital projects
5. Sainsbury's, Manor Road Park & Old Railway Line
6. Outer Harbour, West Pier & the sea front
7. Linear Park, Oliver's Mount & The Mere
8. Middle Deepdale & Cayton

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 08 April 2010

2010-03-31T14:00:00.009+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 08 April 2010 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Outer Harbour Facilities

We are pleased to announce that Doug Kendall, the Project Development Manager for Scarborough Borough Council, has confirmed that he will be able to attend this Thursday's meeting to present the new designs for the Outer Harbour facilities. Doug's presentation will be the main item on the agenda.

You are all very welcome to attend and comment on these proposals, as I'm sure you will need no reminder of how important this scheme is to the continued development and future success of the harbour.

2. Station Area Redevelopment Consultation

A very brief update on the draughting of the master plan and proposed public consultation.

Other items:

Time permitting, the meeting will also include an initial 'rough cut' of a presentation on the subject of 'Place'.

Local Development Framework and Housing Allocations:

As for our recent discussions regarding the Local Development Framework, Housing Allocations and a future strategy for Scarborough, we are very pleased to announce that the Town Team accepted the proposal to adopt this as one of their key future agenda items. We will of course continue to contribute to the debate as Urban Space, and it is very good news that a matter of such significance will now be aired at Renaissance's principal forum.

In addition to the above, we will as usual carry the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including when appropriate the following items:

1. Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital
2. Raising Design Standards & the Planning Process
3. Strategy, Funding & the Management Investment Plan
4. The Spa Complex & other capital projects
5. Sainsbury's, Manor Road Park & Old Railway Line
6. Outer Harbour, West Pier & the sea front
7. Linear Park, Oliver's Mount & The Mere
8. Middle Deepdale & Cayton
9. Scarborough's street scene

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 11 March 2010

2010-03-01T01:00:00.005Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 11 March 2010 and will start at 19h15.

SBC - Consultation on charges for planning advice

Please note that if you wish to respond the closing date for this consultation is Wednesday 03 March 2010.

Agenda

The first two items on the agenda will be brief, but nevertheless important updates:

1. Station Area Redevelopment Consultation

Details of the consultation process, including details of the three options, can still be found at:

SBC - Station Area Redevelopment Options

2. Outer Harbour Facilities

Additional funding for a revised design review and stakeholder consultation.

The third and main item on the agenda will be:

3. Local Development Framework and Housing Allocations

A continuation and drawing to a conclusion of our recent round-table discussions on the Local Development Framework, housing allocations and the future of Scarborough.

Details of the Local Development Framework can be found at:

SBC - Local Development Framework Planning Consultation

In addition to the above, we will as usual carry the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including when appropriate the following items:

1. Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital
2. Raising Design Standards & the Planning Process
3. Strategy, Funding & the Management Investment Plan
4. The Spa Complex & other capital projects
5. Sainsbury's, Manor Road Park & Old Railway Line
6. Outer Harbour, West Pier & the sea front
7. Linear Park, Oliver's Mount & The Mere
8. Middle Deepdale & Cayton
9. Scarborough's street scene

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 11 February 2010

2010-02-08T23:55:00.011Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 11 February 2010 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Station Area Redevelopment Consultation

We have been contacted by SNAP Architects to say that they are still open to consider feedback on the three options presented for the redevelopment of the Station area as part of the ongoing consultation process. So if for whatever reason you were unable to reply earlier, or you have any new thoughts, now is your chance, but they must be submitted by the end of next week at the absolute latest.

Details of the consultation process, including details of the three options and an official downloadable response form, can be found at:

SBC - Station Area Redevelopment Options

2. Charging for Pre-Application Planning Advice

The Planning and Development Committee are to seek comment from interested parties on the possibility of charging clients for certain types of pre-application advice.

This item will be discussed as part of our thread on Raising Design Standards.

Details of the Council's proposal can be found under Item 12 of last week's Planning & Development Committee meeting:

SBC - Charges for Planning Advice

3. Local Development Framework and Housing Allocation

The main item on the agenda will be a continuation of last month's round-table discussion on the Local Development Framework, housing allocations and the future of Scarborough, particularly in light of the Planning Committee's narrow 6-5 vote in favour of approving the outline planning application for High Mill Farm, Scalby. This is particularly important, as it was stated at the Planning meeting that there would be a Community Design Stage, and the USG need to agree whether we think we should be involved or what other comment / action is appropriate.

Further details of the Local Development Framework can be found at:

SBC - Local Development Framework Planning Consultation

Further details for the proposed development at High Mill Farm, can be found at:

09/00717/OL - High Mill Farm - Scalby

In addition to the above, we will as usual carry the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including when appropriate the following items:

1. Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital
2. Local Design Review Panel
3. The Spa Complex
4. Linear Park, Oliver's Mount & The Mere
5. Middle Deepdale & Cayton
6. Sainsbury's, Manor Road Park & Old Railway Line
7. Urban Space 'Scrapbook'
8. Scarborough's street scene

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Planning Decision Archive - 2010

2010-02-08T22:00:00.016Z

Deadline Extension - LDF Planning Consultation

2009-12-24T00:20:00.002Z

Please note that the official consultation period for both the Core Strategy Development Plan and the Housing Allocations Development Plan has now been extended until Sunday 31 January 2010.

Further details of all documents relating to the process, including links to an on-line consultation form, can be found at:

SBC - Local Development Framework Planning Consultation

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 14 January 2010

2009-12-24T00:15:00.007Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 14 January 2010 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

As the last few meetings have been somewhat hectic due to an extensive programme of activity, this month a more relaxed agenda is proposed. Hence, this meeting will take the opportunity to review last year, leading on to a general discussion about what people feel are the most important issues at the moment and what we would like to see addressed over the coming months.

In addition, as the deadline for the LDF consultation has been extended, we may if those present are still interested, return to that subject and possibly within context discuss the outline application for the proposed development at High Mill Farm.

Further details of the consultation process, including an on-line response form, can be found at:

SBC - Local Development Framework Planning Consultation

Further details for the proposed development at High Mills Farm, can be found at:

09/00717/OL - High Mill Farm - Scalby

Also, in light of the recent announcement and debate surrounding Poundland taking over the old Woolworths store on Westborough, it might be interesting to consider whether we think Scarborough's street scene has improved in recent years:

SEN - New Poundland Store

Further to the above, we will as usual carry the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including when appropriate the following items:

1. Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital
2. Local Design Review Panel
3. Station Area Redevelopment Plan
4. The Spa Complex
5. Management Investment Plan
6. Outer Harbour Design Competition
7. Linear Park, Oliver's Mount & The Mere
8. Sainsbury's, Manor Road Park & Old Railway Line
9. Market Square
10. Urban Space 'Scrapbook'

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 10 December 2009

2009-12-04T02:45:00.004Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 10 December 2009 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Housing Allocations Development Plan

The principle item on the agenda will be a discussion about the Borough Housing Allocations Development Plan, currently undergoing public consultation as part of the drafting of the new Local Development Framework. The debate will not concern itself with specific individual sites; but will instead concentrate on the overall strategic distribution of housing. Specifically to consider whether it would be better to create a 'new town' across the belt of Middle Deepdale, Eastfield, Crossgates, Seamer and Irton; or whether we would favour a more distributed model, with perhaps new urban housing concentrated in the Dean Road and Station areas of the town.

Further details of the consultation process, including a list of exhibition dates around the Borough, can be found at:

SBC - Housing Allocations Development Plan

2. Station Square Proposals

The second item on the agenda will be a brief re-visit of the proposals for the Station Square area of the town. The public consultation phase has now been extended until Friday 11 December 2009, affording us with an opportunity to hopefully agree upon a succinct Urban Space take on the presented options.

Further details of the consultation process, including details of the three options and an official downloadable response form, can be found at:

SBC - Station Area Redevelopment Options

In addition to the above, we will as usual carry the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including the following items:

1. Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital
2. Local Design Review Panel
3. The Spa Complex
4. Management Investment Plan
5. Outer Harbour Design Competition
6. Linear Park, Oliver's Mount & The Mere
7. Sainsbury's, Manor Road Park & Old Railway Line
8. Market Square
9. Urban Space 'Scrapbook'

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 12 November 2009

2009-11-09T02:15:00.006Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 12 November 2009 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Station Square Proposals

Following the initial consultation exercise undertaken earlier in the year, possible options for the future of the site are now available for public comment.

Doug Kendall, a senior project manager for Scarborough Borough Council, will be officially presenting the proposals in conjunction with the Hull-based Architectural firm appointed to the lead the consultation exercise, SNAP Architects, and the transport consultants, Local Transport Projects.

The presentations will detail three clear design options, exploring the key themes of Sustainability, Community & Green; Arts, Culture & Leisure; and Business & Retail respectively, in order to facilitate ‘compare and contrast’ discussions.

In addition to the chance to discuss the various options following the presentations, forms will be made available at the end of the meeting for members of the public wishing to formally comment on the proposals.

This is everyone’s chance to have a stake in the exciting future of what already possesses the key elements to become Scarborough’s most impressive and dramatic civic space!

2. Scarborough Live Project '09 - Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital

International Design Competition

A full update on the student's progress and the Council's response to the call for a design competition.

Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital - USG Response

Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital - Town Hall Response

SBC: Planning Committee - Dean Road

In addition to the above, we will as usual carry the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including the following items:

1. LDF & Housing Strategy
2. Local Design Review Panel
3. The Spa Complex
4. Management Investment Plan
5. Outer Harbour Design Competition
6. Linear Park, Oliver's Mount & The Mere
7. Sainsbury's, Manor Road Park & Old Railway Line
8. Market Square
9. Urban Space 'Scrapbook'

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Dean Road - Design Workshop

2009-10-30T09:00:00.019Z

The students of architecture from the University of Sheffield, who are currently producing the design competition brief for the area of Dean Road and St. Mary's Hospital, will be holding a Charrette (an urban design and architecture workshop) at the YMCA from 11h00 - 15h00 this Saturday 31 October 2009:Come along for an informal day of design & discussion on what you want to see on a site in Scarborough, and happening in the future. We'll work in groups with local architects, students and members of local groups to get our vision across.

The work we produce will show the kind of response an open ideas competition might produce, and raise the profile of the site we’re looking at – enhancing the work already being done in terms of a development strategy by raising the overall aspirations of the site.

See you on Saturday!

Dean Road - Town Hall Response

2009-10-19T16:30:00.004+01:00

Please find below a copy of the Town Hall response to the USG's request regarding a call to hold an International Design Competition for the area of Dean Road and the site of St. Mary's Hospital:

"While the running of a project by Sheffield University in respect of the site may yield some useful suggestions as to how the site could be developed, it is not considered that an international design competition would be appropriate. It has also been agreed that officers will assist, the University, where appropriate in the running of a live project. Although it is a generous offer a competition is not proposed in the Brief for the following reasons:

- The Brief considers a whole range of possible options for development, of which housing is one. It would be difficult to define the scope of a competition, while there is such uncertainty.

- It could jeopardise the timescale relating to the disposal of the Depot and securing a beneficial use of the site.

- This would be a matter for a developer to decide on at a later stage.

- It could falsely raise public expectations as to the type and form of development which may proceed.

- Unknown implications on Council resources.

- The Council would expect any development proposals to be forwarded to an appropriate independent Design Review Panel for scrutiny at an early stage in the life any planning application, thus ensuring that a high standard of design is maintained."

-----

A reply to this statement will be posted shortly.

Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital - USG Response

Dean Road - Weekend Consultation Events

2009-10-16T04:05:00.015+01:00

The students of architecture from the University of Sheffield, who are currently producing the design competition brief for the area of Dean Road and St. Mary's Hospital, will be holding a couple of consultation events this weekend to which you are all invited:

Saturday 17 October 2009

Two temporary community forums are being set up in Scarborough this Saturday. We hope you can stop by for cakes and a chat about what you feel would make Scarborough a better place to live. It will be a chance to get your ideas and opinions on the future of the Dean Road site heard, by a group of architecture students working to develop a new agenda for the site.

You can find us at Sandside or the old car park on lower Dean Road (Wrea Lane) from 12pm on Saturday.

Sunday 18 October 2009

Reconnect with Scarborough’s green spaces this Sunday, join the walk from town out to Peasholm Park.

We’ll meet at 12 noon on the green outside the town hall to start our Sunday afternoon scenic stroll.

-----

If you happen to be around Scarborough on either of these two days, please find time to support their endeavours, as our contribution is vital in ensuring that the competition proposal reflects the true thoughts and ideas of everyone interested in the future of the town.

Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital - USG Response

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 08 October 2009

2009-10-01T21:30:00.004+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 08 October 2009 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Scarborough Live Project '09 - Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital

International Design Competition

We are privileged to have with us a group of Sheffield University architecture & urban design students who are currently preparing a competition brief for a possible international urban design competition for the area of Dean Road and St. Mary's Hospital. The students will be presenting their thoughts and research to date and will be looking to encourage a lively debate on what people feel the future of the site could be, with a view to producing a truly inspirational vision statement for the competition. This is of course happening against the background of the production of the current draft development brief and we hope that this project can play its part in positively influencing the development of the area.

This exciting 6-week 'live' project is the second of its kind to be held in Scarborough in consecutive years (last year's project gave us the 'The Old Railway Line' proposals, research & marketing strategies) and the students' input promises once again to be of extreme value to the town.

2. Local Design Review Panel

We have now received a response from the Borough Council, with respect to their current position on the desirability and / or viability of establishing a local design review system for potential planning applications. The meeting will be given an opportunity to comment on their reply and discuss how further progress can be made on this issue.

In addition to the above, we will as usual carry the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including the following items:

1. Management Investment Plan
2. Outer Harbour Design Competition
3. Station Area consultation process
4. Linear Park
5. The Spa Complex
6. Market Square
7. Manor Road Park & Old Railway Line
8. Urban Space 'Scrapbook'
9. Housing Strategy

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 10 September 2009

2009-09-07T01:05:00.005+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 10 September 2009 and will start at 19h15.

Agenda

1. Dean Road Consultation

Members are advised that the period of consultation for the area of Dean Road and the site of the former St. Mary's Hospital has been extended. A copy of the Urban Space Group response can be found on the blogsite and members will be provided with a further opportunity at the meeting to comment if they so wish.

2. Management Investment Plan

There will be a short overview of the draft Yorkshire Forward backed Management Investment Plan and what this may mean for the Renaissance capital projects planned for the next five years. A full presentation by the Town Hall will be made at this month's Town Team and all members of Urban Space will be encouraged to attend.

3. Design Review Panels

A report on the current progress on the setting up or otherwise of a Design Review Panel for the Borough. Some reference will be made to the recent planning applications for The Spa Complex and the proposed Health Village on the old site of the Rugby Club.

4. Review of objectives for 2009

Members will remember that at our December meeting in 2008 (notes attached), we discussed a number of priorities for the year ahead. As we now reach September, it is perhaps a good time to look at what was suggested, review progress and decide on what the group should concentrate on for the remainder of the year.

The Chair would like to suggest that the following should receive the main focus of our attention:

a) Design Review Panels
b) Support for the proposed Dean Road sustainable urban residential design competition
c) Response to the Station Area development consultation

In addition to the above, we will as usual carry the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including the following items:

1. Linear Park
2. Outer Harbour Design Competition
3. Station Area consultation process
4. The Spa Complex
5. Market Square
6. Manor Road Park
7. Old Railway Line - The Cinder Track
8. Urban Space 'Scrapbook'
9. Housing Strategy

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Dean Road & St. Mary's Hospital - USG Response

2009-09-07T01:00:00.005+01:00

Following a meeting of the Urban Space Group, held on Thursday 20 August 2009 at the Renaissance Office, Falconer's Road, Scarborough; the following comments are submitted for the consideration of Scarborough Borough Council, with respect to the draft development brief for Dean Road and site of the former St. Mary's Hospital:

Dean Road Development Brief

We confirm that the Urban Space Group fully support the proposal from Evan Ferguson that the area should be largely given over to a sustainable urban housing development, and that the best way to progress this strategy would be through the organisation of an international design competition.

As Evan states in his letter to Hugh Smith, dated the 12th August 2009, we believe that there is much potential in exploring this idea for the residential elements of the site. The orientation of the site and of the existing road grid is ideal for a solar development, and the views to the castle and moor would guarantee a great deal of interest.

A competition, if run on an international basis and under the aegis of a professional organisation, such as the Royal Institute of British Architects, has a great deal to offer Scarborough:

1. It would attract the international design press and (at least) national media coverage, with the attendant benefits of exposure and advertising for the area.

2. It would reinforce Scarborough’s current title as 'most enterprising town'.

3. It would increase the land value of the residential portion, as interested teams of designers and developers should compete to build each portion of the site.

4. It would increase the value of each individual property within the development, with the cachet of being a competition-winning design.

5. It would increase tourism in the short, medium and long-term, as similar competitions have done all over Europe, and in Glasgow and Milton Keynes.

We are particularly keen to encourage this scheme, especially as we understand that through Sheffield University, Evan would be able to facilitate the drafting of the competition brief as part of one of their Master's degree community based "Live" projects this Autumn. Also we would recommend that we work closely with Yorkshire Forward and RIBA's competition office in Leeds.

With respect to any potential concerns regarding the drafting and management of such a competition, we would like to stress that we do not believe that it would be in conflict with or cause any delay to the production of the Development Brief for said area:

1. All that would be required is a few lines inserted into the Development Brief to the effect that a parallel Urban Housing Competition was being run and that developers were encouraged to adopt / pay attention to the winning schemes.

2. The six weeks for the "Live" Project runs from early October to mid-November, this would fit neatly within the timetable for finalising the Development Brief.

3. It would not restrict potential development by stating that particular areas must be housing, but on the contrary, would promote a freer and more constructive interpretation of the site.

4. Would by necessity encourage a higher standard of design and co-operation, a situation very unlikely to be achieved by just handing the whole site over to a single developer.

5. Potential infrastructure costs would not be a deterrent, as careful urban design layout would ensure that roads, drains etc. would be dealt with within individual competition areas as PART of each site, and not fall to the responsibility of the Council.

Finally, although Urban Space are primarily advocating a residential approach, we do believe that there is adequate scope across such a large area for the inclusion of other business (Class B1), community, leisure, health and small scale convenience retail uses, provided these are integrated within a cohesive and moderated overall plan for the site. Indeed, we understand that Policy S7 of the Local Plan already identifies the site of St. Mary's for a range of complimentary town centre uses, providing it meets with a number of stated requirements. In particular, with respect to:

'(b) direct pedestrian links are provided with Aberdeen Walk and the town centre...'

We would support the extension of this idea to create a green link from Aberdeen Walk, through the site and onwards to the west of the town.

However, we do not support or advise the setting of a large, extended supermarket within the centre of the site. As not only would this be a waste of a valuable and interesting development opportunity; a current traffic impact assessment report would we feel rule out any such utilisation of the area.

Further to this, we find particularly regrettable the comments made in paragraph 8.15 of Version 2 of the Dean Road Development Brief (our italics):

'Particularly if a substantial part of the site were to be occupied by a single user or users, housing would help to make efficient use of areas surplus to requirements, especially around the margins'

and

'The proportion of land could increase if the amount of land required for larger scale commercial or community uses proves restricted.'

The inferred relegation of housing to mere infill does not suggest that the current briefing being drafted is sensitive to local residential needs nor indeed reflecting best practice in urban design.

09/01304/FL - The Spa Complex - USG Response

2009-09-07T00:55:00.003+01:00

The Urban Space Group would like to state that we are in general approval of this planning application and are pleased to see continuing efforts being made to maintain and enhance The Spa building and its environment.

The modification to the stage and other associated changes within the Grand Hall, the reception area and the 'Long Bar', and the pathway leading down to the Spa from the Spa Bridge are all fine; subject to the usual conditions and controls pertaining to the choice of materials, colour, quality of work and so forth.

We are pleased to see the introduction of a shared space scheme on the road leading to the Spa, but note the loss of parking (and thereby also the loss of 'ad hoc' changing facilities for surfers). We believe therefore, it is important that before this particular aspect of the re-development is undertaken, the proposed associated improvements to the both the Aquarium Top car park and the 'doughnut' are approved and completed.

We are less convinced by the proposed temporary roof structure suggested for the Sun Court. Although we do not disapprove of such a roof structure, we feel that the one indicated is somewhat perfunctory and clumsy in its execution and would query the choice of colour for the canvassing.

With respect to the two pavilions shown for the terrace area, it is understood that they would be used to house visitor information and act as a display area for temporary exhibitions amongst other functions, and the intent to improve the old terrace area is a laudable one. However, we would ask whether their rather nondescript and characterless design justifies their inclusion within the overall programme at the present time, and would hope that if they are taken forward, more interesting and worthwhile structures are forthcoming.

Given this, we feel that certain elements of the scheme could have benefited from direct consultation between the architects and a representative group such as ourselves or a Design Review Panel, prior to its submission as a planning application.

In summary, we are happy to support the application if the above comments can be taken into consideration.

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 09 July 2009

2009-07-06T01:20:00.003+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 09 July 2009 and will start at 19h15.

The first main item on the agenda will be to consider the potential acquisition and development of the area within the town identified as Market Square, as outlined in the original Kissing Sleeping Beauty documentation. This item has been included at the request of Roger Foster of the Civic Society, and Roger will be leading us through the key points.

The second main item on the agenda will be to consider the reserved matters application for a mixed-use Health Village on the site of the Old Rugby Club, details for which can be found at:

09/01240/RM - Old Rugby Club - Newby

Details of the previous successful outline application can be found at:

06/02283/OL - Old Rugby Club - Newby

As ever, we will also include all the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including the following items:

1. Manor Road Park
2. Outer Harbour Design Competition
3. Station Square consultation process
4. Dean Road
5. The Spa
6. Design Review Panels
7. Urban Space 'Scrapbook'
8. Linear Park
9. Sainsbury's

Please note that contrary to previous announcements, there will not be a presentation and consultation relating to the Dean Road area from Scarborough Borough Council. It is now understood they intend to hold a series of exhibitions during August, at which, members of the general public will be able to view a range of potential options and will be given an opportunity to make their observations known.

Further details will be posted shortly.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 11 June 2009

2009-06-07T14:00:00.000+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 11 June 2009 and will start at 19h15.

The main item on the agenda will feature a presentation from two Scarborough architects on a new proposal for a Linear Park or Green Link between The Mere, Weaponess, Scarborough Railway Station, Valley Gardens and The Spa.

As ever, we will also include all the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including the following items:

1. Manor Road Park - after the recent CABE SpaceShapers event
2. Outer Harbour Design Competition
3. Station Square consultation process
4. Design Review Panels
5. Urban Space 'Scrapbook'

Further details will be posted shortly.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - Notice - 19h15 Thursday 14 May 2009

2009-05-04T23:45:00.000+01:00

*** IMPORTANT NOTICE ***

Please be aware that there is no public meeting this month due to the unavailability of our usual accommodation at the Royal Hotel.

An update on current projects and issues will be circulated to all those on the contact list.

The next public meeting of the Urban Space Group will now be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 11 June 2009 and will start at 19h15.

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 09 April 2009

2009-04-05T21:21:00.004+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 09 April 2009 and will start at 19h15.

The meeting will feature a one-off urban design exercise on the area surrounding Scarborough's railway station and will offer everyone an opportunity to contribute to the current consultation process.

As ever, we will also include all the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including the following items:

1. CABE SpaceShapers - area adjacent to Woodland Ravine bridge
2. CABE SEA-Change proposals - the Spa and surrounding area
3. Outer Harbour design competition
4. 08/02439/FL - Community Centre Site - Oxcliff
5. 09/00320/FL - Oasis Restaurant - Royal Albert Drive
6. Housing Strategy

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Manor Road Playground - Saturday 28 March 2009

2009-03-27T01:15:00.007Z

Between 11h00 and 15h00 on Saturday 28 March 2009 there will be an open public consultation event at Manor Road Playground - the area adjacent to the Woodland Ravine road bridge over the old cinder track. The purpose of the consultation is to seek the opinions of the local residents regarding the playground and surrounding area, in order to help draw-up an appropriate costed development plan for associated improvements.

The consultation will take three forms:

1. SpaceShaper Questionnaire - A standard questionnaire facilitated by CABE, that tries to gain an understanding of what people feel about the space. Further details can be found by clicking the following link:

http://www.cabe.org.uk/public-space/spaceshaper

2. Arts and Crafts - A fun bit aimed mainly at children and young people, where they'll be given the opportunity to design and build an ideal play area. It's hoped that BEAM will also be in attendance to provide other supporting activities. Further details about BEAM can be found by clicking the following link:

http://www.beam.uk.net/index.php

3. Post-It Planning - A looser consultation with big aerial photos and plans of the site along with examples of good quality open spaces and play facilities. Post-its and marker pens will be provided for people to suggest ideas and make comments. This will also include a look at landscape design with Groundwork North Yorkshire.

In order to support all the activity, we'll be providing a large marquee to protect everyone from the weather, a BBQ for 200 and music.

Everyone is welcome to attend, so please take the opportunity to come along and share your ideas.

The Mere & Oliver's Mount - USG Response

2009-03-10T23:30:00.000Z

Following a meeting of the Urban Space Group, held on Thursday 19 February 2009 at the Royal Hotel, Scarborough; the following comments are submitted for the consideration of the Cabinet of Scarborough Borough Council, with respect to the master plan proposals for the Mere and Oliver’s Mount:

Mere & Oliver’s Mount Country Park Proposals

1. Commercial Development

On balance, the USG recognised the need for a commercial operator to be involved but were concerned that the critical mass of the lodges was not too big and that they were designed appropriately. The USG was also concerned about the prospect of over development and would prefer the Lodges to be limited in number and in smaller groups rather than 260 in one site which they considered would be an over intensification of use.

In addition, it was stressed that it will be important to carefully plan and layout any such development, so as to avoid creating the appearance of a gated community within an area that has been set out as a public country park for the benefit of the people of Scarborough and its visitors.

It was apparent that this was potentially the most contentious aspect of the proposals presented; and whilst tentative support was offered given the reality of funding such a project, it is expected that the Council will pay particular care to ensure that a proper balance is maintained between the public realm and commercial interest, and this can be demonstrated.

The USG would also be interested to hear from the Council if there were any other plans to seek commercial involvement, such as within the area dedicated to extreme sports and outdoor pursuits, or visitor centres.

2. Land Ownership and Council Assets

There was some expression of concern over the potential transfer of land and other Council assets into commercial ownership. It was suggested that perhaps ideas such as leasehold agreements involving 30 year short-term leases and partnership profit sharing schemes should be considered instead.

However, as with all matters pertaining to aspects of the site’s commercial development, it was understood that no detailed consideration of such matters can have yet been undertaken, as this will only become possible once approaches have been made to the commercial sector seeking expressions of interest.

Once there is a better understanding of the commercial reality of sustaining the project, there is an expectation that the Council will exercise due care in all such decisions and will explain why those decisions were taken.

3. The Mere

The users of the Mere want assurances that it will be maintained to a required standard, having regards to its fishing and recreational uses including removal of silt and algae growth and maintain the investments the angling club have made to date.

4. Traffic

The USG requested due consideration of access by traffic to and within the area. A Traffic Impact Assessment will be required and facilities for cycling and walking must be an integral part of the product on offer. Off-road cycling was supported and reference was made to fitting in with Scarborough Cycle Strategy routes.

It expected that particular attention will be paid to the impact of the resulting increase in traffic to the site due to the presence of residential lodges and other commercial activity. It was suggested that consideration should be given to providing some means of access to or extended use of the park & ride, such as the provision of taxis or perhaps more preferably a shuttle bus service to the centre of the site.

5. Middle Deepdale

The USG wanted careful consideration of the links and green belts associated with the Middle Deepdale development. They did not want to see the proposed Middle Deepdale Link Road severing or impeding the links with Oliver’s Mount. Careful design of the proposed road bridge was advocated. Again footway and cycle links will be important.

6. Eastfield

The USG supported the provision of a green corridor to link to the existing residential areas to the south of site.

7. Project Management

The USG agreed with the Chairman that good project management, to include a clear phasing agreement, change management procedures and ongoing consultation, was necessary to ensure that the scheme was delivered in-line with stakeholder aspirations.

8. Design Review

Although there is yet to be established a formal pre-application design review procedure as part of the Council’s planning control; it is recommended that both Council and developers, should wherever possible, take advantage of any opportunity to consult with any like body or organisation prior to the actual submission of any planning application; to seek advice, guidance and support on all matters relating to the planning and design of all buildings, public space and other facilities.

9. Auto 66

The USG noted the aspiration of Auto 66 for a helicopter-pad, but wanted it to be carefully designed and located.

Summary

The general ethos of the Masterplan was supported however the USG wanted assurances regarding the above and that the outcomes of the consultations would be fully articulated and acted upon by the Council.

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 12 March 2009

2009-03-04T23:30:00.000Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 12 March 2009 and will start at 19h15.

Main item:

The Spa - A presentation from Doug Kendall on the proposals currently being drawn up for the next phase of The Spa's development and the surrounding area, including the underground car park, the 'doughnut' and the approaches to The Spa itself. Key sources of potential funding will include Yorkshire Forward and hopefully a successful bid to CABE's Sea Change initiative. Doug is a Project Development Manager at the Town Hall and this is our opportunity to discuss these ideas with him.

We will also be taking a quick look at the revised planning application submitted for the café on Royal Albert Drive, details for which can be found at:

09/00320/FL - Oasis Restaurant - Royal Albert Drive

And considering a new design for the construction of ten apartments on the site of Oxcliff Community Centre, details for which can be found at:

08/02439/FL - Community Centre Site - Oxcliff

As ever, we will also include all the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town, including the following items:

1. Station Square consultation exercise
2. CABE SpaceShaper - area adjacent to Woodland Ravine bridge
3. Outer Harbour design competition
4. Sandybed Court
5. Housing Strategy

Further details will be posted shortly.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 19 February 2009

2009-02-16T22:47:00.003Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will now be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 19 February 2009 and will start at 19h15.

Main items:

The Mere and Oliver's Mount - Presentation from Alex Richards on the new Master Plan for the area. This will be the last opportunity for you to comment on these proposals before the final report is submitted to the SBC Cabinet.

In response to feedback already obtained in the public consultations held in May last year, and subject to the necessary funding, the master plan proposes the provision of a mix of natural space, woodland meadows, walks, cycle trails and bridleways, visitor centre and water sports such as angling and rowing. As stated in the Master Plan Information Note, it also 'identifies areas for commercial type development opportunities such as the possible creation of an extreme sports centre, hotel and eco-lodges to support the community element...' and 'will also meet the aspiration of providing a green corridor from the proposed Middle Deepdale development into the town.'

Further details regarding the master plan can be found by clicking on the following link:

SBC - The Mere & Oliver's Mount

Saturday's Scarborough Evening News report on the proposals can be found at:

SEN - 07 Feb 2009 - The Mere & Oliver's Mount

Everyone is encouraged to attend the meeting as this really will be your last realistic opportunity to discuss these proposals with Alex before the final report is drafted. If there are any detailed issues you would like to raise, Alex would appreciate it if you could forward any such questions to myself before the meeting, so that we may provide Alex with a little time to prepare an appropriate response in advance.

Fantasy Forest - Revised plans for the signage and lighting on 'Fantasy Forest' have now been submitted and are available for viewing. You may remember that as a result of our comments on the previous proposals, the submission was withdrawn for further consideration. The opportunity has now arisen for us to judge if this latest version is an improvement!

Details of the application can be found on the Council's planning portal by clicking on the following link:

09/00185/AA - Olympia Buildings - Foreshore Road

As the application was submitted only last week, comments to the USG on the design will be considered up to and including the date of our next meeting in March.

In addition to the principal agenda items, there will also be opportunity to hear updates on the following:

1. Station Square consultation process
2. CABE SpaceShapers - area adjacent to Woodland Ravine bridge
3. CABE SEA-Change proposals
4. Outer Harbour Design Competition
5. Sandybed Court
6. Housing Strategy
7. Future Vision 09

Further details will be posted shortly.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - CANCELLED - 12 February 2009

2009-02-03T14:07:00.023Z

*** Please note that due to the bad weather this ***

*** meeting has been cancelled ***

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will now be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 19 February 2009 and will start at 19h15.

The agenda will remain unchanged.

Planning Decision Archive - 2009

2009-02-03T13:00:00.008Z

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 08 January 2009

2009-01-04T22:50:00.008Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 08 January 2009 and will start at 19h15.

Main items:

Sandybed Court - housing scheme
The first item of the evening will be a discussion of the planning application scheme for 53 new dwellings (a mix of three and two storey flats and two storey semi-detached and town houses) at the above site, providing an opportunity to offer feedback on the proposals.

Further details regarding the planning application can be found by clicking on the following link:

08/02418/FL - Yorkshire Coast Homes - Sandybed Court

Future Vision 09 - disused spaces
Landscape Architect, Nick Robinson will introduce the concept of 'Future Vision' (an annual design award aimed at encouraging the regeneration of disused/underused spaces in our towns & cities in promotion of the creation of sustainable communities) with a view to finding possible sites in and around Scarborough which might benefit from further design attention (towards a potential entry in the 'Open Spaces' category).

Further details regarding Future Vision 09 can be found by clicking on the following link:

Future Vision 09

In addition to the principal agenda items, there will also be opportunity to catch-up on the status of the CABE SEA-Change proposals (focusing on the Spa); and hear updates on the following:

1. Station Square proposals
2. The Mere proposals (as a quick recap prior to February's meeting)
3. CABE SpaceShapers project (Barrowcliff site)
4. Housing Strategy

Finally, there will be an opportunity to recap on last meeting's discussion re: the Forward Planning aspect of the USG's agenda and to add any further thoughts with respect to the group's priorities for 2009.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 11 December 2008

2008-12-08T23:35:00.002Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 11 December 2008 and will start at 19h15.

The main subject for the meeting will be Design Review Panels. These have been set up by a number of local authorities and it has been claimed that they can make a contribution towards raising the standard of design within the built environment. The objective for the meeting will be merely to introduce the idea and to discuss whether such an approach would be suitable for Scarborough.

As ever, we will also include all the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 13 November 2008

2008-10-31T13:32:00.007Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 13 November 2008 and will start at 19h00.

Main items as follows:

1. The students from Sheffield University will be returning to present their final recommendations, and handing over copies of all relevant material, covering their recent work on the cinder track of the old Scarborough to Whitby railway line.

As part of the project, the students have also produced a web site and podcast. These can both be found by clicking on the following link:

The Cinder Track

Please note that the students are still adding material to the site and you are advised to keep checking back to see the latest revisions.

2. Richard Flowitt will be providing an insight into how an architect approaches a design for a building revision, drawing upon Fantasy Forest on Foreshore Road as an example.

3. Consideration of the current proposals for the new signage and lighting for Fantasy Forest, now to be renamed 'Scarborough Olympia'. Further details of the planning application can be found by clicking on the following link:

08/02052/AA - Olympia Buildings - Signage & Lighting

As ever, we will also include all the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 09 October 2008

2008-09-24T13:40:00.003+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 09 October 2008 and will start at 19h00.

A group of students from Sheffield University are currently undertaking a six week project on the path of the old Scarborough to Whitby railway line. Their main objective will be to work in conjunction with local stakeholders to produce a phased master plan for a series of linked development projects. This is particularly relevant to the work of the Friends of the Old Railway Line, who are currently assembling bids to support a number of both small and large scale works along the track. In order to assist both parties and to facilitate wider consultation, this Thursday's meeting will be given over entirely to the students and the friends of the line.

Although essentially a one item agenda, we will be hoping to include at the end a short update on Fantasy Forest, and cover any plans, projects or other news as time permits.

It promises to be an interesting evening and hope many of you will be able to attend.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h15 Thursday 11 September 2008

2008-09-03T15:27:00.007+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 11 September 2008 and will start at 19h15.

In the first half of the meeting we will be reacquainting ourselves with the Foreshore; but this time, instead of looking at the Futurist, we will take the opportunity to consider 'Fantasy Forest' and its relationship to the gardens of St. Nicholas Cliff.

If you would like to gain a little more familiarity with the subject prior to the meeting, Marcus Whitmore (planning officer at the Town Hall) will be leading a conducted walk of the area for those who are able to arrive earlier. The walk will commence at 18h30 from the foyer of the Royal Hotel and will take us down through the gardens onto Foreshore Road and then back up to the hotel in time for the start of the meeting at 19h15. You are all welcome to join us.

We hope this will prove an interesting little exercise to start our new season of meetings after the summer break.

In the second half of the meeting, we will be considering Benchmark's new planning application for the old Open Air Theatre as part of the The Sands development. Details for the application can be found by clicking on the following link:

Council Planning Portal: 08/01584/FL - Benchmark - Open Air Theatre

As ever, we will also include all the latest news, issues and project updates from around the town.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 10 July 2008

2008-06-27T01:05:00.001+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 10 July 2008 and will start at 19h00.

The main item on the agenda will be the future of the town centre.

1. Renovation of 8 – 9 York Place, Scarborough

Last year voted one of Scarborough’s ‘most hated buildings’; now fully renovated, what do we think? Please take an opportunity to view the bar before the meeting.

07/01756/FL – Renovation of Bar Frontage – York Place

2. Shared Space

An introduction to shared space; literally the shared use of space by pedestrians, cyclists and motor vehicles.

3. Town Centre Expansion – A strategy for the future

A brief overview of the report recently submitted to the SBC Cabinet followed by debate.

Items for the agenda are invited.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Links to SBC Website

2008-06-05T13:20:00.013+01:00

Due to a slight change in addressing method, links to some content on the SBC website are no longer correct.

This will be amended as soon as possible.

UPDATE: Tuesday 10 June 2008

All links under 'Latest News' and 'Planning Decision Archive' have now been corrected.

All links to the planning portal are still valid.

UPDATE: Wednesday 31 March 2010

All links have now been updated and checked.

- ticket closed

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 12 June 2008

2008-05-14T15:57:00.007+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Ballroom of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 12 June 2008 and will start at 19h00.

Main items as follows:

1. Peasholm Gap - Legoland is back!

The amended documents are nos. 91 - 110:

Council Planning Portal: 08/00400/FL - Benchmark - Peasholm Gap - LegoLand, Multi-storey Car-park & Apartments

2. Station Square design brief

3. Town Centre expansion

4. Building a sense of place

In addition to the above items, the meeting will also provide an opportunity for an update on the CABE: Sea Change initiative and a review of the project suggestions put forward so far; plus all the usual news and comments.

Further details will be posted shortly.

Items for the agenda are invited.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 08 May 2008

2008-05-04T21:34:00.008+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 08 May 2008 and will start at 19h00.

Main items as follows:

1. The Mere & Oliver's Mount Consultation

As part of the Council's official programme of public consultation (at the request of Ray Williamson), the Urban Space Group is offering everyone an opportunity to review the three outline schemes currently under consideration and have the opportunity to share comments on the ideas being proposed.

This consultation provides a key opportunity to get involved with the future of this interesting site and make your comments count - all feedback will be recorded and constructive critique and ideas passed on to the Council for consideration and possible absorption into the design development.

Regeneration - Mere & Oliver's Mount Consultation Document

2. 08/00654/OL - North Street Cinema Complex

As an application for outline planning permission for the development has now been received by SBC planning department, we will be reviewing this key (and now well-recognised) project and throwing it open to discussion once again; with a view to developing a formal response on the various aspects of the proposal for reply to the Council.

Council Planning Portal: 08/00654/OL - Shaw - North Street Development

In addition to the above items, the meeting will also provide an opportunity for an update on the CABE: Sea Change initiative and a review of the project suggestions put forward so far; plus all the usual news and comments.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Field Trip - 09h00 Saturday 05 April 2008

2008-04-02T23:00:00.007+01:00

This Saturday we will be joining the 'Friends of the Old Railway Line' to review the stretch of line from Sainsbury's to Scalby Village. The objective will be to identify potential sites for new access points, bins, benches, lighting, signage and other improvements to help develop the track for both cyclists and pedestrians alike.

All findings will be presented at our next Urban Space Group meeting on Thursday 10 April 2008. We will then take the opportunity to assist in producing a phased development strategy for the line, including identifying potential sources of funding.

The walk will start from 'Safe Way Park' under Wykeham Bridge on Wykeham Street, Scarborough and will finish at the site of the new Rugby Club, just north of Scalby. The walk is about 2.5 miles in length and the return will be by the local bus service or on foot!

So if you would like to get involved with something on the ground and in the raw, this is the opportunity for you!

View Larger Map

Multi-map link to Wykeham Bridge: Wykeham Bridge

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 10 April 2008

2008-03-21T12:00:00.006Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 10 April 2008 and will start at 19h00.

The meeting will focus on the development plan for the urban stretch of the old Scarborough - Whitby railway line.

Main items as follows:

1. The Old Railway Line – Development Plan

The line, its current state, and a proposal for phased development.

Field Trip - 09h00 Saturday 05 April 2008

2. Scarborough Borough Council Parks & Gardens

Your chance to talk to Tom Mutton from the Borough Council's Parks & Gardens department. Tom will be making a presentation on their work around the town; and discussing how we and the various friends groups can best support the department, and encourage the care and development of our public space.

3. CABE: Sea Change – £45m Seaside Resort Grants Programme

A briefing on CABE’s new initiative to revitalise England’s seaside resorts.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

08/00400/FL - Legoland - USG Response

2008-03-20T18:30:00.009Z

Following a meeting of the Urban Space Group, held on Thursday 13 March 2008 at the Royal Hotel, Scarborough; the following comments are submitted for the consideration of the Council’s Planning & Development Committee, the Planning Department and the project's developers Benchmark, with respect to the aforementioned application:

Legoland Discovery Centre

The complex comprises the Legoland building (including additional leisure facilities as yet unnamed) and a multi-storey car park with apartment fringe on the opposite side of Burniston Road.

General Statement

The USG heartily welcomed Legoland as a proposal. It was generally agreed that the advent of the brand poses a fantastic opportunity for the town and the Legoland facility will be a great addition to the area, able to be enjoyed by both visitors and locals alike.

Legoland / Leisure Building:

1. The members attending were quite happy with the Legoland building in terms of its appearance, architecture design, layout and so on. There were concerns raised, however, about the proposed building’s juxtaposition against The Sands apartments (currently under construction on The Corner Café site) in terms of a mismatch of scales. To clarify, the Legoland building is proposed to be a comparatively low building at only 2 storeys in height against the much higher residential building adjacent to it and it was felt by those present that a more sympathetic treatment of this transition might be needed to ease the visual impact of the change in scale. The USG, however, is pleased to note such concerns have apparently already been taken in hand and it is anticipated that the tower detail, situated to the seaward end of the Legoland site, will be extended in height to mediate the difference in levels.

2. It was also stressed that the USG would be very keen to see the employment of a high level of design detailing and good quality materials to ensure that the finished building would be an outstanding, high class product which made best possible use of this opportunity to create a significant new addition to the town’s built fabric.

Multi-storey car-park & apartments:

1. The USG were less happy about the implementation of the car park and apartment block. There was particular concern shown towards the Burniston Road elevation. The ‘living wall’ proposed for this aspect (though a very welcome and interesting idea) is, we understand now, in jeopardy as a design possibility on account of the relatively harsh coastal climate, and it is unclear what might be proposed in its place to disguise the car park’s sheer facade. Possible substitutions have included a ‘waved’ elevation, or possibly attaching panels or louvres to the façade, or even an alternative ‘living’ façade using projected images.

2. In response to the first point, it was proposed that the residential apartment ‘curtain’ might be extended (i.e. wrapped around the corner) to soften the Burniston Road elevation, thereby also creating an interesting dialogue with the curved element of the Legoland façade on the site opposite.

3. Further concern was raised regarding the expanse of open car parking area (i.e. the roof of the multi-storey car park) which is proposed to extend from Ryndale Drive. It was questioned whether some sort of screening could be achieved through vegetation etc. to reduce the impact of this expanse from the drive itself and from the hotels and so on looking out over it.

4. It was considered that the apartments posed a flat, uninteresting roof-line and were of a repetitive, relatively uninteresting, ‘ungrounded’ design, and was hoped that more time spent might be spent on improving the appearance to achieve a high-quality aesthetic and make more of the sloping site.

Updated Submission

Following the withdrawal of Legoland from the proposal and subsequent modifications to the application, the following amended commentary was submitted:

Further to our previous commentary and subsequent review of the revised application at our meeting of Thursday 12 June 2008; the Urban Space Group now feel moved to object to the proposed development on the grounds that the design is inappropriate for Peasholm.

1. The multi-storey car park

Whilst the meeting accepted that there may well be some justification for a multi-storey car park at this location, it was felt that the architects had not succeeded sufficiently in blending the building into the site. It was seen as just a large block dominating the area. It was noted that the developers had not responded to our previous comments and there were still doubts outstanding concerning the green-wall and the design of the wall of apartments. It was also noted that the choice of vegetation for the wall would be crucial; and further to this, there were still no firm details available regarding a suitable alternative, should ultimately the green-wall be deemed impracticable. We also found it strange that the Borough Council may subsequently take responsibility for the up-keep of said green-wall; we find this unacceptable.

2. Commercial leisure building

With the benefit of more time for further consideration, we are now of the opinion that this building is also inappropriate. Although it could be said that there is nothing particularly wrong with its appearance, indeed some members commented positively on the inter-locking rectangular forms of the elevation to Peasholm Gap, it was felt on balance that it was now shorn of character following the withdrawal of Legoland. Indeed, it was thought difficult to imagine how the design could ultimately reflect the purpose of the building, given that the ultimate function, be it cinema, casino, retail leisure or otherwise, was unknown. The general forms, layout and look of the entire scheme just seem isolated and ill-suited to the site. We are also concerned that its height and nearness to the public highway have created an aspect that is too dominant and urban in character, and consequently not in keeping with this area of Scarborough.

3. Link between the two buildings

The development itself is cut through by a main road. Anyone arriving by car to visit the facilities will have to use the car park and then cross over the road. We do not feel that this has been given adequate consideration. We also note that there is no mention as to how the use of the car park relates to the other attractions that comprise The Sands Development, Peasholm Gap and Peasholm Park itself. It seems that no thought whatsoever has been given to how people will move around the area and interact with the environment. For example, the commercial leisure building terminates abruptly at its western end, without sufficient importance or definition at a point where people will be passing by. This sends out contradictory messages regarding statement of presence and the desire for human scale.

4. Summary

We accept that this is a challenging site, we accept the presence of some form of commercial leisure activity at Peasholm Gap (although a water park would always be preferred), and we accept that there may well be a need for an extended car park. However, as with some other elements proposed for The Sands, we feel that this proposal does not respond appropriately to its location and the lack of an overall approach to landscaping is evident. It provides only a box where commercial activity can take place. It does nothing to enhance the experience of either local or visitor and contributes nothing to the character of Scarborough. It is therefore with regret that we cannot support the scheme as presented.

Full details of the application can be found by following the links at:

Current Planning Applications Under Review

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 13 March 2008

2008-03-08T01:00:00.007Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 13 March 2008 and will start at 19h00.

There are three main items on the agenda:

1. Station Square - an update since the last meeting

2. UR Frame - an idea for a portable installation to encourage people to think about their surroundings

3. LegoWorld, multi-storey car park & apartments - debate on the style and layout of this new proposal

Further details will be posted shortly.

Items for the agenda are invited.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Current Planning Applications Under Review

2008-03-08T00:30:00.019Z

This post contains details of all planning applications currently under review by the Urban Space Group.

As at 01 December 2008:

*** PLEASE NOTE THIS PART OF THE SITE ***
***IS CURRENTLY UNDER REVISION ***

1. Benchmark - construction of 116 new holiday homes with access, car parking & landscaping at Bay View, Northstead Manor Gardens, Scarborough

Council Planning Portal: 07/02394/FL - Benchmark - Bay View

2. Benchmark - LegoLand: Proposed Leisure Development (D2) 7,942 sq m and associated mini adventure golf course together with 1,122 sq m ancillary A1/A3 floor space, multi storey car park 462 spaces, 36 residential dwellings, public toilets and associated highways development at Peasholm Gap, Scarborough

Council Planning Portal: 08/00400/FL - Benchmark - Peasholm Gap - LegoLand, Multi-storey Car-park & Apartments

Key document: 08/00400/FL - Design & Access Statement

There are fifty documents associated with this application. However, the design and access statement is by far the most useful one. Please take time to read through it before our meeting. The document is listed number 50 under the tab 'Associated Documents'.

08/00400/FL - LegoLand - USG Response

3. Shaw - North Street: Mixed use development comprising provision of multiplex cinema (use Class D2), hotel (use class C1), retail units (use Class A1) and restaurants (use class A3) and related facilities and works and including off sheet car parking.

Council Planning Portal: 08/00654/OL - Shaw - North Street Development

Project Prioritisation - Part 1 / 3

2008-01-21T16:10:00.003Z

Please note that these project proposals are a wish list drawn up by the USG and are in no way officially endorsed or as yet recognised by the Scarborough Renaissance Executive, Scarborough Borough Council or Yorkshire Forward.

Potential key projects:

1. Production of plans and long-term development initiative for the Station Square area, including possible land acquisition.

2. Improvements and other Public Open Space issues associated with the urban stretch of the old Scarborough - Whitby railway line.

3. Redevelopment of the Futurist site and links to its surrounding environment.

4. Design work on the West Pier proposal.

5. Public realm improvements and other developments at The Mere and the surrounding area.

New additions:

A. Town Centre expansion.

B. Building a sense of place.

C. Art Gallery refurbishment.

Project Prioritisation - Part 2 / 3

2008-01-21T16:05:00.000Z

Please note that these project proposals are a wish list drawn up by the USG and are in no way officially endorsed or as yet recognised by the Scarborough Renaissance Executive, Scarborough Borough Council or Yorkshire Forward.

Other potential projects:

6. Refurbishment / sale / investment in the Aquarium Top underground car park together with the Cliff Lift.

7. Semi-pedestrianisation / environmental improvements of the St Nicholas Cliff area between the St Nicholas Hotel and Grand Hotel.

8. Redesign of Falconers Square in conjunction with changes to traffic priority in Falconers Road and St. Nicholas Street.

9. Preparation of designs for the reduction of through traffic and improvement of pedestrian priority in St Nicholas Street and the southern end of St Thomas Street.

10. As per 'Kissing Sleeping Beauty' repave Westborough, Bar Street, Huntriss Row and sections of St Nicholas Street, St Thomas Street and Newborough.

11. Acquire the old rolling staking rink owned by the St Nicholas Hotel on Vernon Road for residential / car parking / offices.

---

12. Second stage feasibility study of the outer harbour including investigation of new public space with restaurant and onshore facilities.

13. Additional floodlighting to the Castle walls, Town Hall, west side of St Nicholas Cliff involving the St Nicholas Cliff and others in a coordinated floodlighting scheme - 'a lit backdrop to the South Bay'.

14. Engagement of architects and urban designers to prepare plans for the redevelopment of much of Foreshore Road between the Olympia and Eastborough traffic lights with a view to encouraging property owners to improve / redevelop.

15. Feasibility study to promote development on the eyesore site called the Grand Hall Terrace between the Grand Hall and Foreshore Road.

16. Architectural study of the potential of built development on the Quay Street car park and Eastborough car park.

17. Money for shop front grants to improve the appearance of Eastborough / Sandside.

18. Architectural feasibility study of the Eastborough / Queen Street block known as the Argos Building as envisaged as a public space in 'Kissing Sleeping Beauty'.

Project Prioritisation - Part 3 / 3

2008-01-21T16:00:00.000Z

Please note that these project proposals are a wish list drawn up by the USG and are in no way officially endorsed or as yet recognised by the Scarborough Renaissance Executive, Scarborough Borough Council or Yorkshire Forward.

Other potential projects:

19. Money for town centre traffic flow / management study with a view to removing excess traffic and increasing pedestrian priority.

20. Acquisition and architectural study of potential development land in St Thomas Street to create retail / office / residential redevelopment.

21. Architectural study, continuing the architectural feasibility / scheme for the vacant space next to Londesborough Lodge.

22. Further design work to development the Derek Latham study of improvements around the Spa to create residential / hotel / leisure etc. (if possible in conjunction with DEFRA coastal defence monies).

---

23. Procure support of CABE, Prince’s Trust, English Partnerships or similar body to advise on the design coding and master planning for the 1,200 house Middle Deepdale development.

24. Public consultation and other development work associated with the planned expansion of Scarborough's housing provision.

25. Public realm improvements to the area surrounding North Street to link with any potential development of the site.

26. Money for tree planting along the A64 entrance to Scarborough including Seamer Road as envisaged by the 'Green Gateway' in 'Kissing Sleeping Beauty'.

27. Provision of money for a 'revolving fund' where we buy semi-derelict or poor buildings, do them up and sell them on at no cost or a profit.

28. Restoration of South Cliff and Valley Gardens.

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 21 February 2008

2008-01-21T15:30:00.001Z

Please note that the next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held slightly later in the month than usual on Thursday 21 February 2008 and will start at 19h00.

There are three main items on the agenda:

1) North Street Cinema Development
2) Proposed changes to Station Square
3) Bay View Holiday Apartments at The Sands

Further details will be posted shortly.

Items for the agenda are invited.

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 10 January 2008

2008-01-07T00:25:00.001Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held in the Cavalier Suite of the Royal Hotel on Thursday 10 January 2008 and will start at 19h00.

The meeting will mainly concentrate on the Shaw's £70m development proposal for the North Street car park; including a discussion regarding the potential for drafting design statements covering particular areas of Scarborough, and exploring the possibility of encouraging pre-application design reviews.

Further details will be posted shortly.

Other potential items for the agenda are invited.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Planning Decision Archive - 2008

2008-01-07T00:20:00.014Z

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 13 December 2007

2007-12-08T00:15:00.001Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held at the Royal Hotel on Thursday 13 December 2007 and will start at 19h00.

The main item on the agenda will be a presentation from Graham Price, Head of Property Services at Scarborough Borough Council, on Benchmark's proposals for the Northstead Manor Gardens area of The Sands development. Further details will follow shortly.

Other potential items for the agenda are invited.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 08 November 2007

2007-11-04T23:30:00.000Z

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held at the Royal Hotel on Thursday 08 November 2007 and will start at 19h00.

Due to Renaissance Reunion there was no meeting in October 2007.

The provisional agenda is yet to be drawn up, but it will include a continuation of the debate surrounding the site for a new multiplex cinema in Scarborough; a follow-up from October's Renaissance Reunion; and updates on the Sands Development, the Futurist, and the consultation on Scarborough's future Housing Allocation Strategy.

Other potential items for the agenda are invited.

Please see 'Quick Notes' for further updates on Renaissance Reunion.

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Renaissance Reunion

2007-11-01T16:55:00.007Z

Renaissance Reunion took place at The Spa and Scarborough's harbour side on Friday 12 October and Saturday 13 October 2007.

I would just like to take this opportunity to thank everyone who helped over the two days to make the event a success.

The outcomes from Saturday's consultation are currently under review. Updates will be posted as and when available.

Examples of some of the feedback received can be viewed at:

Scarborough's Future - Renaissance Reunion Feedback

If you haven't yet caught up with what Renaissance Reunion was all about, background information can still be found at:

Yorkshire Forward - Renaissance Reunion

Please note that this item has been removed from the YF site. For further information, please try:

Yorkshire Forward - Renaissance Reunion Search

Planning Decision Archive - 2007

2007-09-30T22:00:00.002+01:00

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 13 September 2007

2007-07-26T01:12:00.000+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held at the Palm Court Hotel on Thursday 13 September 2007 and will start at 19h00. The hotel is on the opposite side of Falconers Road to the Renaissance Centre.

The provisional agenda is yet to be drawn up, but it is likely to feature an update on the changes to The Sands development; and an introduction to the recent Council Local Development Framework document on future Housing Allocations in the Scarborough area.

Please don't forget that in August we will be holding our one day workshop on the Futurist and Foreshore Road. The date has now been set for Saturday 18 August 2007 and will be held at the Renaissance Centre. Places will be limited to around 20 and further details on what's happening and how to book will be circulated soon.

Please see 'Quick Notes' for further updates on the workshop.

Multi-map link to the offices: Scarborough Renaissance Office

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 12 July 2007

2007-07-11T17:20:00.001+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held at the Royal Hotel on Thursday 12 July 2007 and will start at 19h00.

The hotel is on St. Nicholas Street and will provide us with a larger and more comfortable room for our presentations and discussion.

The meeting will focus on the planning system and its implications for Renaissance; featuring a presentation from Gordon Somerville, Head of Planning Services at Scarborough Borough Council.

Following this, there will be a discussion about the revised proposals for the Sands Development, including the potential development of a multiplex cinema on the site of the old Atlantis water park.

Scarborough Evening News Article: North Bay To Get Cinema

Multi-map link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Agenda

1. Welcome

2. Apologies

3. Minutes of the previous meeting - 14 June 2007

4. Matters Arising

5. The Planning System - 1 hour

A question & answer session will follow Gordon's presentation. If you've ever wondered what the planning system is about; this is the session you've been waiting for.

6. The Sands Development: Proposed Changes to Plan - 20 mins

7. Report from the Executive meeting - 02 July 2007 & 13 June 2007

Commitment to Kissing Sleeping Beauty.

8. Town Team & Station Square Follow-up

Follow-up from May's Town Team meeting and June's Town Team and USG meetings. Including Most Hated Buildings, The Futurist, Foreshore Road and Station Square.

9. Planning, Projects & Issues

Round-up of a number of key subjects. Including:

a) Seamer Road Park & Ride
b) Aquarium Top & The Underground Car Park
c) The Sitwell Centre
d) Weaponess Conservation Area
e) The Football Club

10. Nomination for Historic Environment Champion

11. Any other business

12. The next Urban Space Group meeting

If there is anything else you would like to see added to the agenda; please contact me as soon as possible and time permitting, I will try and include it within 'any other business'.

The meeting will finish by 21h00 at the latest.

If you would like to receive information from the USG and are not on the mailing list, please contact Linda at the Renaissance Office:

Contact Scarborough Renaissance

Planning & Development Committee - 14 June 2007

2007-06-28T20:27:00.001+01:00

The following key panning decisions were taken by the Council's Planning & Development Committee meeting on Thursday 14 June 2007:

07/00936/FL -
Removal of condition 3 of decision 06/00867/OL which requires a dwelling with no dormers windows or other apertures in the roof on land to rear of 73 High Street, Burniston - APPROVED (unanimous)

07/00866/RM -
Erection of eight dwellings on site of LPG Depot, Church Hill, Reighton - APPROVED (unanimous)

07/00874/FL -
Single storey side extension; internal alterations and new disabled facilities for Burniston Methodist Church, High Street, Burniston - APPROVED (unanimous)

07/00818/FL -
Change of use from B1 / B8 to D2 permitting additional space to indoor children's play centre for 'keep fit zone', Units 3A & 4A, Hopper Hill Road, Seamer - REFUSED (8-7)

07/00854/FL -
Change of use from shop & cafe to cafe and youth drop-in centre, 2 Moor Lane, Newby - APPROVED (10 for, 1 abstention)

07/00681/RM -
Building of 13 2-storey and 1 3-storey office buildings with car parking, electric sub-station, landscaping and associated works, Scarborough Business Park, Dunslow Road, Eastfield - APPROVED (8-1, 2 abstentions)

Cllr. Clegg said the modern design of the first set of buildings was "soulless, dull and uninspiring". Some other members tended to agree with her. The developer had provided an artist's impression which made the buildings look yellow, with blue glass windows. The officer assured the committee that the walls would be in different colours of brickwork to give variety, rather than the uniform yellow shown on the artist's impression. He declared that the buildings would be brick not stucco. The blue glass was just artistic licence. Several councillors persisted in thinking the design disappointing.

Cllr. Cluer was concerned about environmental issues and energy conservation. She asked, for example, whether the windows would open (presumably so that air-conditioning would not be constant). She did not get a straight answer, but was assured that such issues would have been considered.

07/00879/FL -
Construction of new electricity sub-station, Peasholm Gap, Scarborough - REFUSED (9-6)

The USG objected to the application on the grounds that the design was unsuitable given its prominent location.

Please click on the planning application reference to view details.

Swiss Cottage Sold

2007-06-26T23:05:00.002+01:00

Situated at the southern end of the Spa Bridge and probably the oddest building in the Council's portfolio; it appears they have finally been successful in selling the dwelling affectionately know as the Swiss Cottage.

Hopefully the new owners will choose a more appropriate colour scheme than the current sky blue and white. We understand that at the time of its last renovation, paint scrapings had shown that this was its original colour; but we can't help thinking it's not really suitable for the location. Dark green and cream perhaps?

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 12 July 2007

2007-06-26T22:28:00.000+01:00

MIMA - Middlesbrough Institute Of Modern Art

2007-06-11T14:10:00.002+01:00

First in an occasional series, highlighting interesting new public buildings from around the country.

Winner of an RIBA (Royal Institute of British Architects) award, created by the famed Dutch architect Erick van Egeraat and built at a cost of £14.5m, MIMA represents a new breed of public building.

Designed as a result of public consultation, it's a relatively small building set within 5 acres of redeveloped land opposite the Town Hall, and is indicative of a move away from 'trophy' buildings towards architecture that is more in keeping with local regeneration and community needs.

Interestingly, the public square was designed in conjunction with Dutch landscape architects West 8.

Associated link:

Middlesbrough Institute Of Modern Art

Links (to be updated):

RIBA Awards 2007 - North East
Erick van Egeraat - MIMA
Guardian Arts - MIMA (pdf)

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 14 June 2007

2007-06-07T23:51:00.001+01:00

The meeting will be held on Thursday 10 May 2007 and will start at 19h00.

In a change to the advertised venue, the meeting will now be held at the Palm Court Hotel. The hotel is on the opposite side of Falconers Road to the Renaissance Centre and will provide us with a larger and more comfortable room for our presentations and discussion.

The meeting will focus on developments surrounding proposals for Station Square.

Multi-map link to the offices: Scarborough Renaissance Office

Agenda

1. Welcome

2. Apologies

3. Minutes of the previous meeting - 10 May 2007

4. Matters Arising

5. Station Square - 1 hour 30 mins

a) Presentations
b) Discussion
c) Conclusions
d) Report

We hope that by the conclusion of this item, the meeting will have reached a consensus as to which course of development for the Station Square we would prefer to support.

6. Report from the Action Group Leaders' meetings - 04 June 2007 & 13 June 2007

Closer co-operation between Action Groups; prioritisation of projects; the development of short, medium & long term plans; and an update on the objectives & itinerary for the Renaissance Reunion event.

7. Report from the Council's Planning & Development Committee meeting - 24 May 2007

Please see Recent Planning Decisions for a list of key judgements made at the last Planning & Development Committee meeting. This item will also include a brief update on all other current planning issues and Renaissance projects.

8. Any other business

9. The next Urban Space Group meeting

If there is anything else you would like to see added to the agenda; please contact me as soon as possible and time permitting, I will try and include it within 'any other business'.

The meeting will finish by 21h00 at the latest.

If you would like to receive information from the USG and are not on the mailing list, please contact Linda at the Renaissance Office:

Contact Scarborough Renaissance

Planning & Development Committee - 24 May 2007

2007-06-07T22:07:00.001+01:00

The following key panning decisions were taken by the Council's Planning & Development Committee meeting on Thursday 24 May 2007:

06/02283/OL -
Mixed-use health village, on site of Scarborough Rugby Club Ground, Scalby Road, Newby - DEFERRED (9-8)

In principal the concept was well received but the committee felt the decision should be deferred as there were some concerns regarding the height of the central building at 3 stories; proximity of buildings to The Close; the hospital's flat roof; and a link path to open ground.

07/00054/CC -
Modified proposal for Seamer Road Park & Ride site for North Yorkshire County Council - HEAVILY CRITICISED

A desperately inadequate proposal for Scarborough's primary Park & Ride site; poor landscaping; poor layout; poor access; poor facilities; poor quality of design and materials; the application was rightly condemned by both Councillors and Council Officers. The decision is pending the meeting of NYCC Planning Committee on 05 June 2007. Both Gordon Somerville and Cllr. Lucy Haycock to represent.

02/00320/FL -
Renewal of temporary permission for Coble Landing Roundabouts Ltd., Coble Landing, Filey - APPROVED (unanimous)

07/00291/FL -
Change of use from shop to take-away pizza place, 10 Osgodby Lane, Osgodby - APPROVED (9-4)

Local opposition but to no avail. Application concerned outstanding condition which was met.

07/00668/FL -
Demolition of detached house and construction of four three-bedroomed semi-detached houses, 79 Cross Lane, Newby - APPROVED (2 against)

Councillors felt this was a significantly improved proposal following the re-submission of a previously refused application. Surprisingly light opposition given concerns expressed regarding the loss of 'Executive quality housing', especially in relation to this site.

07/00796/FL -
Construction of new dwelling, land adjoining 43 High Street, Burniston - REFUSED (11-2)

07/00233/FL -
Construction of new dormer house with attached garage, land west of 9 Garton Lane, Hunmanby - APPROVED (unanimous)

06/02273/FL -
Residential development of 14 flats on Warehouse Site, King Street, Scarborough - REFUSSED (unanimous)

The application was opposed by both the USG and Scarborough Civic Society. Criticism centred on the general design of the building and also the main southern aspect of the construction. It was felt that this would necessarily put a stop to any further development along King Street; affecting any proposed inclusion of the King Street car park as part of the future vision for the Futurist or indeed any other build.

However, there was no objection in principal to development of flats on the site of the former warehouse, and it was hoped the developers would return with a more sympathetic proposal.

07/00169/FL -
Demolition of existing premises and construction of 10 dwellings on site of Kelley's Motor Body Works, Ewart Street, Scarborough - APPROVED (unanimous)

Councillors praised the proposal; stating that the design was in keeping with the surrounding housing and they felt it was the right type of development for the area.

07/00626/FL -
Amendments to Phases 2B & 3 of scheme previously agreed under Ref. 02/01141/FL to include an additional 23 dwellings at Edgehill Re-development Site, Seamer Road, Scarborough - APPROVED

07/00644/FL + 07/00645/LB -
New toilets & sealing of door opening, The Crescent Hotel, Belvoir Terrace, Scarborough - APPROVED

07/00697/AA
Erection of double-sided advertisement panel, Falsgrave Community & Resource Centre, Seamer Road, Scarborough - APPLICATION WITHDRAWN

Somebody ought to point out that this place is about a mile away from Falsgrave...

Please click on the planning application reference to view details.

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 14 June 2007

2007-05-11T13:07:00.001+01:00

The next meeting of the Urban Space Group will be held at the Renaissance Centre on Thursday 14 June 2007 and will start at 19h00.

The meeting will focus on developments surrounding proposals for Station Square.

Multi-map link to the offices: Scarborough Renaissance Office

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 10 May 2007

2007-04-29T12:40:00.000+01:00

The meeting will be held at the Renaissance Centre on Thursday 10 May 2007 and will start at 19h00.

The meeting will include a session on Quality in Design, presented by the respected architect Richard Flowitt. Examples will be taken from around Scarborough; both good and bad!

Multi-map link to the offices: Scarborough Renaissance Office

Agenda

1. Welcome

2. Apologies

3. Minutes of the previous meeting - 12 April 2007

4. Report from the Executive meeting - 30 April 2007

New date and itinerary for Renaissance Reunion; strategic planning; changes to the structure of Scarborough Renaissance; and an update on the Sub Regional Investment Plan – SRIP.

5. Station Square - 20 mins

Outcomes from the previous meeting and further action.

6. Urban Space Group future programme - 20 mins

Finalising the Agenda for the current year (to August 2007); and planning for the Town Team meeting on Tuesday 15 May 2007. Further details to be circulated at the meeting.

7. Report from the Council's Planning & Development Committee meeting - 19 April 2007

Please see Recent Planning Decisions for a list of key judgements made at the last Planning & Development Committee meeting. This item will also include a brief update on all other current planning issues and Renaissance projects.

8. Quality in Design - 45 mins

A session presented by the respected architect Richard Flowitt. Examples will be taken from around Scarborough; both good and bad!

9. Any other business

10. The next Urban Space Group meeting

If there is anything else you would like to see added to the agenda; please contact me as soon as possible and time permitting, I will try and include it within 'any other business'.

The first half of the meeting should be completed by 20h00, leaving the rest of the meeting to Quality in Design with a bit of tidying up at the end. The meeting will finish by 21h00 at the latest.

I hope to circulate copies of all papers for the meeting by Thursday 03 May 2007. If you would like to receive information from the USG and are not currently on the mailing list, please contact Linda at the Renaissance Office:

Contact Scarborough Renaissance

Planning & Development Committee - 19 April 2007

2007-04-23T15:19:00.000+01:00

The following key panning decisions were taken by the Council's Planning & Development Committee meeting on Thursday 19 April 2007:

07/00465/FL -
House on Plot 91, 29 Cawthorne Crescent, Filey - REFUSED (7-6)

07/00441/FL -
4 bungalows on land to rear of Main St., Seamer - APPROVED

07/00679/FL -
In-fill Atlantis pool with quarry stone - APPROVED

07/00678/FL -
Placement of funfair on site of Atlantis pool - APPROVED (conditions to be agreed, temp. till October)

06/02491/LB -
Consent for train information boards etc. at Scarborough Station - APPROVED

07/00227/FL -
Erection of 12 flats on site of 94 Filey Rd. - REFUSED (7-7 Chair's vote against)

07/00511/FL + 07/00517/LB -
2 replacement windows to rear of Flats 5 & 6, The Crescent, Scarborough - APPROVED (wood encasement type, positive example)

07/00590/FL -
Catering trailer, stall etc., Windmill site, Foreshore Rd., Scarborough - APPROVED

07/00460/FL -
New replacement Community Centre, Green Ln., Whitby - APPROVED

07/00476/RG3 -
Use of 'pitch & put' for temporary car park - APPROVED

07/00491/FL -
6 houses on land to east of junct. of Stonecross Rd. & Highfield, Whitby - APPROVED

07/00598/LB + 07/00596/FL -
New first floor balcony & smokers area, The Shambles, Market Pl., Whitby - REFUSED (heavily criticised)

Please click on the planning application reference to view details.

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 12 April 2007

2007-04-02T13:54:00.001+01:00

The meeting will be held at the Renaissance Centre, Falconers Road, Scarborough, YO11 2EN.

Multi-map link to the offices: Scarborough Renaissance Office

Agenda

1. Welcome

2. Apologies

3. Minutes of the previous meeting - 08 March 2007

4. Report from the Executive meeting - 02 April 2007

A report from the Executive meeting, covering the appointment of the next Chair for Scarborough Renaissance, and an update following the Town Team meeting with Cynthia Welbourn.

5. Urban Space Group future programme

A brief update on the programme for the next few months.

6. Report from the Council's Projects & Partnerships Committee meeting - 26 March 2007

A brief update on the report for the first phase of the West Pier consultation.

7. Report from the Council's Planning & Development Committee meeting - 29 March 2007

Including the decision to refuse the development of 14 flats on the site of 18 East Park Road, Scalby (planning application - 06/02665/FL), the decision to approve the building of a new 37 bedroom extension to Scalby Manor Hotel (planning application - 06/02639/FL), and a proposal to demolish The Sitwell Centre to build 13 ‘affordable’ houses (planning application - 07/00544/FL). Update on NYCC proposals for Seamer Road Park & Ride.

8. Scarborough's Design Champion

Does the Urban Space Group wish to nominate anyone for this position?

9. Station Square

a) Scope of proposal - 15 mins.
b) Discussion - 45 mins.
c) Summary & the way forward - 15 mins.

At least 75 minutes will be devoted to this item. All documentation has been forwared by e-mail.

10. Any other business

11. The next Urban Space Group meeting

If there is anything else you would like to see added to the agenda; please contact me as soon as possible and time permitting, I will try and include it within 'any other business'.

Items 4 - 7 will only be brief updates and I expect to spend around 10 minutes discussing the 'Design Champion'. Most of the meeting will be given over to the Station Square consultation, aiming to finish by 21h00.

USG Meeting - 19h00 Thursday 08 March 2007

2007-03-06T22:27:00.000Z

The meeting will be held at the Renaissance Centre, Falconers Road, Scarborough, YO11 2EN.

Multi-map link to the offices: Scarborough Renaissance Office

Agenda

1. Welcome

2. Apologies

3. Minutes of the previous meeting - 08 February 2007

4. Report from the Executive meeting - 05 March 2007

Report from the Executive meeting, mainly pertaining to education and also preparations for May's 'Renaissance Reunion'. At present, it is unclear if the Urban Space Group will be required to do anything specific for the reunion event. If we are, perhaps we could discuss one or two ideas at this meeting, finalising them in April?

5. Station Square

As much about the future objectives of the Urban Space Group as the potential Station Square initiative. A brief update on the Design Champion will be included within this item, plus potential workshop and conference opportunities for ourselves.

6. Report from the Council's Planning & Development Committee meeting - 01 March 2007

Report from the last meeting of the Council's Planning Committee, specifically considering the current state of play regarding the Seamer Road Park & Ride. In addition, we will also cover: Spa Ramps, King Street, West Pier and The Futurist.

7. Website & electronic communication

As the Scarborough Renaissance website is due to be updated, we thought it would be an appropriate time to ask what sort of features we would like to see incorporated within the renewed design. The current site is very limited (we can't even add copies of the minutes), so there are a number of obvious items such as agendas, minutes etc.; but as examples, would we also want to create dedicated sections for specific projects, examples of good design or planning applications we are currently scrutinising? Would this be possible?

The website for Scarborough Renaissance can be found at:
http://www.scarboroughsfuture.org.uk

8. Any other business

9. The next Urban Space Group meeting

If there is anything else you would like to see added to the agenda; please contact me as soon as possible and time permitting, I will try and include it within 'any other business'. I will aim to conclude the meeting by 20h45, but I will be prepared to extend the time a little, should we feel it necessary that further discussion of a topic would be of benefit to the group.

USG Meeting Diary

2007-02-28T23:45:00.030Z

Meetings of the Urban Space Group are normally held at the Royal Hotel on the second Thursday of each month, and now start at 19h15. There is no meeting in August, although we do usually organise a workshop or other field activities during the summer.

Our next meeting dates are as follows:

19h15 Thursday 12 January 2012
19h15 Thursday 09 February 2012 - cancelled due to weather
19h15 Thursday 16 February 2012 - re-arranged meeting
19h15 Thursday 08 March 2012 - cancelled
19h15 Thursday 15 March 2012 - re-arranged meeting
19h15 Thursday 12 April 2012
19h15 Thursday 10 May 2012
19h15 Thursday 14 June 2012
19h15 Thursday 12 July 2012

Past meeting dates:

19h00 Thursday 12 June 2008
19h00 Thursday 10 July 2008

19h15 Thursday 11 September 2008
19h00 Thursday 09 October 2008
19h00 Thursday 13 November 2008
19h15 Thursday 11 December 2008

19h15 Thursday 08 January 2009
19h15 Thursday 12 February 2009 - cancelled due to weather
19h15 Thursday 19 February 2009 - re-arranged meeting
19h15 Thursday 12 March 2009
19h15 Thursday 09 April 2009
19h15 Thursday 14 May 2009 - no public meeting
19h15 Thursday 11 June 2009
19h15 Thursday 09 July 2009
19h15 Thursday 20 August 2009 - emergency meeting
19h15 Thursday 10 September 2009
19h15 Thursday 08 October 2009
19h15 Thursday 12 November 2009
19h15 Thursday 10 December 2009

19h15 Thursday 14 January 2010
19h15 Thursday 11 February 2010
19h15 Thursday 11 March 2010
19h15 Thursday 08 April 2010
19h15 Thursday 13 May 2010
19h15 Thursday 10 June 2010
19h15 Thursday 08 July 2010
19h15 Thursday 26 August 2010 - special meeting
19h15 Thursday 09 September 2010
19h15 Thursday 14 October 2010
13h30 Thursday 04 November 2010 - special meeting
19h15 Thursday 11 November 2010
19h15 Thursday 09 December 2010

19h15 Thursday 13 January 2011
19h15 Thursday 10 February 2011
19h15 Thursday 10 March 2011
19h15 Thursday 14 April 2011 - cancelled
19h15 Thursday 21 April 2011 - re-arranged meeting
19h15 Thursday 12 May 2011
19h15 Thursday 09 June 2011
19h15 Thursday 14 July 2011

19h15 Thursday 08 September 2011
19h00 Thursday 29 September 2011 - special meeting
19h15 Thursday 13 October 2011 - cancelled
19h15 Thursday 20 October 2011 - re-arranged meeting
19h15 Thursday 10 November 2011 - cancelled
19h15 Thursday 17 November 2011 - re-arranged meeting
19h15 Thursday 08 December 2011

Items for the agenda are invited.

Bing-Maps link to the Royal Hotel: Royal Hotel

Urban Space Group - Temporary Site

2007-02-28T23:35:00.002Z

The aim of the Urban Space Group is to actively promote excellence in architecture and urban design and encourage creativity in the use of all public space.

This blogsite has been established to provide information relating to the latest meetings of the Urban Space Group.

The main site for Scarborough Renaissance can be found at:

http://www.scarboroughsfuture.org.uk

If you would like to receive information from the USG and are not on the mailing list, please contact the Renaissance Manager Nick Taylor at the Town Hall.